Dealing with Secondary Vaginismus: A Newlywed’s Story

by | Jun 22, 2021 | For Women, Uncategorized | 3 comments

Dealing with Secondary Vaginismus

What happens when you develop vaginismus LATER–after you’ve already started having sex?

How is this even possible? And can you get over it?

That’s what we’re going to talk about today!

We’re in the middle of our pelvic floor series, and we’ve been touching on vaginismus this month, talking about the causes of vaginismus and steps to overcome it (including seeing a pelvic floor physiotherapist!). 

Today I want to change gears and share a personal story from a reader about secondary vaginismus–vaginismus that develops later. At one point you could have pain-free sex, but then something changes.

I love Jordan’s insight into her own story, which is still ongoing. 

So here’s Jordan Mullins, from Happily Ever Mullins, telling us her story!


Sheila Wray Gregoire

My husband, Nathan, and I were virgins when we got married last May.

Everything was different because of COVID, of course, but some things were the same as I expected, even dreaded—like the butterflies in your stomach, I can’t eat or I’ll puke nervousness I felt the night before and day of our wedding.

Secondary Vaginismus Jordan Mullins WEdding Photo

Our first time having sex, indeed on our wedding night, was mostly focused on intercourse, despite all my mental rehearsals of the loads of foreplay we’d be doing. It didn’t hurt, not in the least, but I was nervous, so we rushed it. I didn’t orgasm that night, nor any other night for three months. (To say I was sexually frustrated would be putting it lightly.)

Then, one blessed day late July of 2020, I did it. With the help of the vibrator my husband bought me, I was able to orgasm for the very first time! I cheered, I cried, and I couldn’t wait for this to become a normal in our marriage.

About a week later was when disaster struck.

Morning sex has never really been my thing, my body couldn’t ever get aroused properly enough for intercourse to be comfortable that early, but that day we were both randomly in the mood for it. I remember feeling like something was off when I first woke up, but I couldn’t put a finger on it.

Not until a sharp, burning pain hit me when Nathan tried to insert his penis. He pulled it back out, covered in what I can only assume now was evidence of a yeast infection. Thus started my now ten-month long journey through secondary vaginismus.

The gynecologist I went to see, about a month after the pain started, was of no help. She didn’t communicate clearly and assumed I knew things when I didn’t. She treated me like the average college-aged young adult woman she saw daily, young women who were having sex regularly before marriage and got the occasional UTI or yeast infection. All my tests came back negative for any sort of infection, yeast or bacterial, so I was left with a suggestion to “watch what I eat”.

I can’t tell you how many times I came back home crying from frustration after a visit with her.

Six months go by before I can get in to see a pelvic floor physical therapist. By this time, I had stubbornly insisted on trying intercourse too many times, so much so that we no longer could even try because the burning pain I felt was so bad. I’d prayed, I’d asked friends to pray, but it hurt so much (physically and emotionally) to attempt intercourse after getting my hopes up, just for it to still burn terribly. A few women in my ministry tried to speak some encouragement into my situation, but they all said something to the effect of, “You can be intimate in other ways!”

As a high-drive, newlywed wife, I felt like none of them understood the pain I was going through.

Yes, our actual sex life looked so much better as the months went by, despite not having intercourse (I’m able to orgasm, we cuddle all the time, Nathan’s heart for my sexual pleasure has only increased over time). But that didn’t make the lack of intercourse, something I thought God wanted for us in our marriage, any easier.

Starting February 3rd, I was able to start seeing my PT once a week for about a month, then once every other week for however long necessary after that.

I ADORE my PT (physiotherapist).

She listens to me, communicates very openly, always lets me know what we’ll be doing, and (most importantly) makes sure I am okay with everything we’re doing. Most of our focus was on getting me to relax my pelvic floor muscles.

You see, that’s why I refer to my condition as “secondary vaginismus”: I didn’t always struggle with pain in sex, but once my body had experienced several traumatic, painful attempts at intercourse, the muscles were refusing to let down their guard. It was incredibly disheartening, every time I looked on the internet for an explanation, and the only times the word vaginismus was used were referring to lifelong pain with entry or post-childbirth. I felt like I was alone with my pain, that no one understood what was wrong with me and that we were never going to get an answer.

Over time, my PT and I made some physical progress (one step forward, two steps back kind of progress), but I felt like God was doing a lot of digging beneath the surface in the meantime.

What’s one of the main reasons our pelvic floor muscles can prevent entry? Fear, not feeling safe, or not being aroused.

I have a major fear of rape and of being forced into sex. I have never been raped, nor would Nathan ever force me to have sex with him, but before all my pain started I felt like intercourse was a mandatory part of sex. Are you following me?

Now that I had the freedom to say no to intercourse, I realized I was scared of no longer having pain and intercourse being mandatory again.

Did Nathan ever say it had to happen? No. Did my brain tell me I had to let Nathan inside if we were having sex? Yep!

And as soon as I realized I was afraid of intercourse being normal again, I had a whole dose of guilt to heap on top. I wanted sex to include intercourse as much as my husband, probably more, so why was I so scared?

God didn’t curse me with painful sex.

I think illnesses, pain, and disease all come from the reality of the fact that we live in a broken world, made broken by sin. Could He have taken it away by now? Yes, but He hasn’t, not fully anyway.

Ever since mine and Nathan’s one year anniversary on May 16th, I’ve heard this line in my head trying to comfort me, that God does not support forced sex. Through the times I can relax and actually enjoy intercourse right now versus the times I grow fearful of obligation and the burning pain returns, He is showing me that He doesn’t make forced sex easy in a marriage. It melts my heart, to know the love and intentionality God has put into marital sex. He has such a heart for it, such a yearning passion for it to be a gift to us—a gift that would unite marriages, bring laughter, and even encourage pleasure.

It’ll take me time to fully realize that for my own marriage.

I’ve had trauma from men in my life using porn that’s caused me to question the mutuality of God’s design for sex. Somehow, I got it in my head that, once my pain goes away, intercourse is the main part of His design. Like everything we’ve been doing through the past ten months, everything that has made sex BEYOND pleasurable, is “less than” just because it isn’t penis in vagina.

That’s completely not true. God made all the sexual pleasure spots on our bodies to be included in what we summarize by saying “sex”, not just the penis and vagina. In my case, it’s taken pain in the vagina to recognize unhealthy mindsets of fear and obligation. I know everybody’s stories are different, especially with such a tender subject, but I hope that hearing mine will make even one woman feel less alone.

Sheila here again: I love the conclusions that Jordan is making from her own journey–that God is showing her that He didn’t make forced sex easy. Our bodies literally rebel against even the notion of it. And as she’s working through that (and I’ve sent her a copy of The Great Sex Rescue to help with that!), she’s starting to see some victory.

That’s how it should be!

If you’re struggling with the obligation sex message, you may also enjoy:

After four years of college and a degree in Psychology, Jordan Mullins has discovered that her passions are people and words. She is an avid believer in the power of vulnerability and sharing, even when it’s super uncomfortable. She adores pretty much anything to do with Disney, wears her hair in a messy bun 99% of the time, and likes to think she’s a pretty relatable human. Jordan is also a newlywed!

Through all her in-person work with ministry and on her blog, Happily Ever Mullins, Jordan seeks to speak life into women, in the hopes that they’ll begin to see life as the bountiful, beautiful gift it has every possibility of becoming

Jordan Mullins

Happily Ever Mullins

Secondary Vaginismus Caused by UTIs and Fear

Can you relate to what Jordan is saying? How her body is reacting to the fear that sex will become an obligation? Let’s talk in the comments!

Related Posts

Written by

Sheila Wray Gregoire


Recent Posts

Want to support our work? You can donate to support our work here:

Good Fruit Faith is an initiative of the Bosko nonprofit. Bosko will provide tax receipts for U.S. donations as the law allows.

Sheila Wray Gregoire

Author at Bare Marriage

Sheila is determined to help Christians find biblical, healthy, evidence-based help for their marriages. And in doing so, she's turning the evangelical world on its head, challenging many of the toxic teachings, especially in her newest book The Great Sex Rescue. She’s an award-winning author of 8 books and a sought-after speaker. With her humorous, no-nonsense approach, Sheila works with her husband Keith and daughter Rebecca to create podcasts and courses to help couples find true intimacy. Plus she knits. All the time. ENTJ, straight 8

Related Posts

These Books Would Have Changed Our Lives

If we had had these Great Sex Guides before we got married, there would be no Great Sex Rescue. No To Love, Honor and Vacuum blog. No Bare Marriage podcast. Why? Because we wouldn't have had years of pain that we had to untangle from, so I wouldn't have started...


We welcome your comments and want this to be a place for healthy discussion. Comments that are rude, profane, or abusive will not be allowed. Comments that are unrelated to the current post may be deleted. Comments above 300 words in length are let through at the moderator’s discretion and may be shortened to the first 300 words or deleted. By commenting you are agreeing to the terms outlined in our comment and privacy policy, which you can read in full here!


  1. Em

    Thank you for sharing your story! This series is so helpful.

  2. n

    It’s heartbreaking that so many women aren’t able to find good answers. I’m so sorry for this woman’s pain and glad she found a good PT. I thought I was a Christian when I started learning about sex in college and there were few Christian resources other than Act of Marriage. I did skim that but when I saw how minimally helpful it was, I went looking for other information from a scientific perspective. This was early to mid 1990’s. I had terrible vaginismus (probably because part of me knew it was bad news to be trying to have unmarried intercourse, no matter what crazy things I idiotically believed that I had been told by socalled Christians who said God “understood”). I remember finding an explanation that it’s a little like having a brand new turtleneck sweater and the neck needs gentle patient stretching with appropriate moisture, so you don’t damage it. I guess I didn’t know so many young women are as sheltered as they are, or so trusting that it will work out without troubles? I wonder how we could do more to get the word out in places that conservative women would see? Maybe libraries that have fliers with info about abuse on the backs of bathroom stall doors, could have a line about making a pelvic floor PT appointment, for before the “first time” whether that’s after a wedding or whenever.

  3. J

    My problem is a little different than Jordan’s….I’m a divorced woman but had incredibly painful sex when I was married. Marital rape was a factor as was the “you must give your husband sex” message. I swallowed a lot of that before I got married and after when things were so bad I and read lots of books written by evangelicals.
    After someone told me I was obligated to give it to him my body froze. Like, we’re driving down the road and she said it is a needed thing and that I must give it to him after we’re married, and it changed every part of my sexual response. I wasn’t able to get turned on after that. Before she said that I had a high/normal sex drive and was really looking forward to getting married and losing my virginity but then she said that and all my body heard was “you’re not important, you don’t matter. give it to him, it’s all you’re good for after you marry him” so we got married and we tried to have sex but I had my period that night and it hurt. so. bad. He wasn’t about to touch me down there since I was bleeding, but he still wanted to have sex, we’d waited all this time and he was expecting sex. We spent a week on our honeymoon and I wasn’t able to get aroused. at all. He didn’t want to spend any time on foreplay becasue he was able to get the whole enchilada now so why go back to kissing and hugging and petting? I stayed with him way longer than I should have but in all our years of marriage I only got him to makeout with me once. I got aroused but he wasn’t interested in sex.
    Okay so that is a bit of the backstory. Now I’m divorced and healing from lots of the trauma but I still can’t get aroused. (Warning, tmi incoming) Sometimes when my period is around the corner I get “some kind of horny” but not actually aroused. Does that even make sense?
    I had a one night stand awhile back. I am not saying it was right of me to do that, but it was a kind of healing thing to have sex with someone that I trusted and wasn’t scared of. I was always scared of my ex….I never relaxed around him. But anyway, so with this one night guy, he and I made out for awhile and I actually got aroused and I can’t tell you how good it felt to feel those feelings again! But then we decided to have a roll in the bed together and while I trusted him and he knew I’d been hurt before and he’d stop it if I wanted him to, I wasn’t able to get aroused once while we were together that night. And even now if I try to use a vibrator or even my fingers, I just can’t get aroused. Is it vaginismus? Is it something else? I don’t know. I’d like to figure it out though because it’s messed up and bothers me.


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *