What if lower libidos aren’t about hormones or biology?
But they’re actually about our early experiences with sex, and how our brains learn about sex?
There’s a study that came out in January in the journal Personality and Social Psychology Review which I’ve seen SO MANY reels made of. It’s really hit the mainstream.
Now, it’s not being reported on entirely correctly (the article’s thesis is that the key formative years for when we learn about sex and get our baseline libido is ages 10-24, and most of the reels are just talking about how any experiences with sex can kill libido), but it’s still fascinating.
And today on the podcast Rebecca and I are going to do something new: we’re going to walk through the whole article together so that you can really understand what it’s saying. I think it’ll be freeing, and will also help people understand themselves!
Or, as always, you can watch on YouTube:
Timeline of the Podcast
00:00 Intro: Why Women Might Not Want Sex (And It’s Not What You Think)
04:19 The Developmental Gap: Why Early Experiences Matter
08:39 The Orgasm Gap Starts at the Beginning
16:09 Who Is Sex Really Supposed to Be For?
22:24 The Risks & Rewards of Sex at Different Ages
26:16 Virginity as a Gift: The Messages We’re Giving Girls
35:56 Have We Lowered the Bar for What Counts as Good Sex?
38:59 Do Christians Actually Have Better Sex? Questioning the Research
48:44 Why Adolescence Is a Formative Window for Sexual Learning
53:40 Purity Culture, Shame, & the Messages Girls Absorb
01:03:54 Hormones, Medication, & the Question of Sexual Development
01:09:05 What the BLOOM Framework Means for Parents & the Next Generation
01:14:02 Conclusion: Porn, Sex Education, & Raising Sexually Healthy Kids
Key Talking Points
1. Women’s lower desire for sex may be learned, not hardwired.
One of the most important ideas in this research is that women’s lower reported interest in sex may not be an inevitable biological difference between men and women. The BLOOM model suggests that early sexual experiences help shape later desire. When girls and young women repeatedly experience sex as disappointing, uncomfortable, or even punishing, they can develop negative associations that influence their sexuality well into adulthood. We need to stop assuming that women are simply wired to want sex less.
2. The orgasm gap isn’t just about biology—it’s about opportunity.
The research makes a compelling distinction: women aren’t inherently less capable of experiencing sexual pleasure, but they are often given fewer opportunities to experience it with a partner. The orgasm gap is particularly striking during first sexual experiences, when men are far more likely than women to reach orgasm. The fact that women’s experiences improve considerably in other partnered contexts challenges the assumption that women’s bodies are somehow less capable of enjoying sex.
3. Early sexual experiences can shape expectations for decades.
Adolescence and emerging adulthood (roughly ages 10–24 in the research) are particularly important developmental windows. During this time, the brain is highly adaptable, identity is taking shape, and experiences can carry enormous emotional weight. If those formative experiences are characterized by shame, fear, inequality, or a lack of pleasure, they can create lasting expectations about what sex is supposed to feel like. And those expectations can be mistaken for natural differences between men and women.
4. We’ve been teaching men to prioritize their pleasure while asking women to accommodate them.
We need to take a closer look at the messages Christian culture gives young men about sex. When pastors joke that a bride should simply stand where her husband tells her to stand and do what he tells her to do on their wedding night, they’re reinforcing a deeply unequal understanding of sex. If we want healthier marriages, we need to stop treating sex as something men receive from women and start teaching couples that mutual pleasure, care, and connection are essential.
5. Purity messages can accidentally teach girls to feel ashamed of their own bodies.
There’s a difference between teaching children Christian sexual ethics and teaching them that their bodies are inherently dangerous or that their sexuality is something to be hidden. Messages about virginity being a gift to a future husband, modesty being a girl’s responsibility, and sexual feelings being inherently threatening can create shame at precisely the time when young people are developing their sense of identity. We can teach chastity without making girls feel that their bodies are the problem.
6. We’ve lowered the bar for what counts as satisfying sex.
One of the more eye-opening observations in this research is that men and women may have very different definitions of good sex. Men are more likely to include pleasure and orgasm in their definition, while women may simply define satisfying sex as sex that wasn’t painful, degrading, or frightening. Over time, women can become so accustomed to having their pleasure overlooked that they stop expecting it. That’s not a healthy standard for anyone’s marriage.
7. We need to rethink how we talk about sexual health, hormones, and medication.
Our discussion raises important questions about how hormonal contraception and antidepressants might affect sexual development, particularly when girls and young women are taking these medications during formative years. The researchers acknowledge that this area needs more investigation. We’re not suggesting that necessary medication should be avoided, but we should be curious about its potential effects and stop treating women’s sexual health as an afterthought.
8. Sex-positive education can actually help protect young people.
Perhaps the biggest takeaway for parents is that teaching children about sexual pleasure and how their bodies work doesn’t mean encouraging them to become sexually active. In fact, understanding their bodies can help young people recognize unhealthy situations, identify red flags, and make safer decisions. We can teach Christian values and boundaries without relying on threats, shame, or fear. Our goal should be to raise young people who understand their bodies, respect themselves and others, and have the tools to build healthy relationships.
Things Mentioned in the Podcast
BARE MARRIAGE ANNOUNCEMENTS
Preorder Fawn, Sheila’s New Book
Get The Whole Story, our sex and puberty course, for 25% off with the coupon code PODCAST: https://baremarriage.com/the-whole-story/
TO SUPPORT US:
- Join our Patreon for as little as $5 a month to support our work (and get access to the book club!)
- And check out our Merch, or any of our courses!
- Give to the Good Fruit Faith Initiative of the Bosko Foundation
- Join our email list!
LINKS MENTIONED:
- Study
- Friday Roundup: Do Evangelical Christians Have Better Sex Than Secular Couples?
- Sheila’s Substack – Atlantic Article Critique
- Lisa Reeves’ article
- Our study on sexual victimization in a church setting and modesty messaging
Did you learn anything listening to what this article reports? Does it make sense to you? Let’s talk in the comments!
Transcript
What if the reason that you don’t want sex isn’t hormonal? It isn’t because you’re female. It isn’t anything biological. What if it’s just because your early experiences with sex weren’t actually that great? That’s what we’re gonna talk about today on the Bare Marriage podcast. I’m Sheila Wray Gregoire from baremarriage.com where we like to talk about healthy, evidence based biblical advice for your sex life and your marriage. I am joined today by my daughter, Rebecca Lindenbach, and we have been sent, multiple people have sent me this article. It is in Personality and Social Psychology Review. And it’s kind of like a meta analysis, except it doesn’t like big statistical stuff. But what it does is it combines like 300 studies that have looked at this thing, and it tries to come up with a new model.
Rebecca
Is it a systematic review or analysis?
Sheila
I think it’s a systematic review, and what it’s doing is trying to come up with a new model of how we understand women’s sexual development and libido. And it’s so much fun. You probably saw a lot of Instagram Reels on this. And yeah, we are going to talk about it today because it’s been a while since we have unpacked a new article. This one’s really, really important. So we’re going to walk through it. Before we do that. Thank you. Of course, to our patrons, I think it was one of our patrons who first sent this to me, and then multiple other people did, too. Our Patreon group is always super fun. On Facebook, we have our meme Mondays where people share their memes. We have our terrible take Tuesdays. We have lots of stuff going on and people just asking for thoughts and how to handle churches and lots of things like that. So you can join our Patreon for as little as $5 a month. And be part of the Facebook group. We’re going to be doing some really cool stuff in the winter at higher tiers, like Joanne is going to be teaching a course on developing sexual ethics.
And yeah, lots of things are going on in her book club of course. Or if you want to support the academic work that we do and the docu series that we’re creating and even more, you can also just give and get a tax receipt in the United States through the good Faith initiative of the Bosco Foundation. We’ll put a link on the podcast notes.
All right. Are you ready for this, Becca? Becca hasn’t actually read this, so. And this is going to be a fun one, because what we’re going to do is I have taken a lot of quotes from it, and I’m going to read the quotes, and I’m going to get Rebecca to translate.
Rebecca
Well we are going to see if I can.
Sheila
What it’s called, this article is called least equal when most teachable. The bio developmental learning opportunities and outcomes model of gender differences and sexuality.
Rebecca
They are calling this their bloom. They made this model that explains the gender differences and experiences of sex and they are calling it bloom.
Sheila
And specifically how that impacts like desire for sex because that’s their big research question. And the authors of this study, we actually quote them a lot. You know, the U of T study that we quote from 2022, it’s the same author. So this is out of University of Toronto. So yay plug for my hometown. I don’t live there anymore. But that’s where I grew up. And, yeah. So great research is doing this. All right. They have both an academic abstract and a public abstract in this, which I think is so beautiful. So they’ve already, I was going to say dumbed it down, but that’s insulting.
Rebecca
They have simplified the jargon.
Sheila
Simplified the jargon. So why don’t we only read the public abstract okay. Do you want to do that?
Rebecca
Sure. Here’s what they say. Gender differences in sexual enjoyment are among the largest in psychology and have remained so over decades despite other advances in gender equality. The gender gap in sexual pleasure, for example, has gained widespread attention and is increasingly discussed as an explanation for gender differences in sexuality. Here, we spotlight the largest but least discussed gender gap in sexual enjoyment, the developmental gap. We review evidence that adolescence is not simply a vulnerable period for sexual health, but a window of opportunity for learning how to have healthy, enjoyable and desirable sex, and one where an equal opportunity is lacking. We propose women get the least equitable sex during this window, when they are primed to learn from it. And this learning informs sexual interest, thereafter generating acquired differences that are often mistaken for inborn ones. We close with recommendations for ensuring equal opportunities for healthy sex and sexual health across genders.
Sheila
Okay. And this is a very long article. Of course we have a link in the podcast notes so you can look it up too. So what they’re essentially saying is, look, everyone knows that there is a pleasure gap. And people often say, well, the women, the reason women don’t want sex as much is because they’re not enjoying it as much. And sure, that might be true, that. But what they’re saying is. But there’s another thing that hasn’t been researched, and that’s the developmental gap and what they define adolescence and the the area of time that they are studying as between 10 to 24. Yeah.
Rebecca
So in essence, your sexual the, the time of your life where you are learning about and experiencing sex for the first time on average. Yeah. And so that could be at 22. They are not saying the 13 year old should have sex. No. That’s always whenever we talk about something like this. They talk about adolescence or development. We have people who are like the godless, the socialist, the academic elites want our 13 year old to have orgies. And yeah, no, this includes a 21 year old who just got married. Yeah. It’s about that. What’s your sexual debut experience?
Sheila
Yeah. Yeah, exactly. And, and and our experiences of sex actually, like, we all have experiences of sex, even before we have sex, which is, which is one of the things that they’re talking about. So they’re talking about the pubertal period, the adolescent period and the early adult period. So 10 to 24. And I mean, that would be us when we got married.
Rebecca
And I had a child at 24. Yeah, I was yeah.
Sheila
Yeah. So did I, I had you at 24. So you know, this encompasses how a lot of evangelicals get married before 24. And so, you know, if you waited for the wedding night, this study is talking about you as well. And even if you got married later, it’s still talking about you in some of the other terms. So, but what I really want to focus on, the reason that we want to look at this article is because it, again, shows that it isn’t that women automatically want sex less, or even have less of a capacity to enjoy sex. In fact, the article very much shows that they have a greater capacity to enjoy sex and a greater capacity to learn about sex and learn to get better. It is just simply that women have negative associations at the time where the brain is the most plastic and is learning the most about sex. And so as our brains are developing, like your brain develops as much during adolescence as it does in toddlerhood.
Rebecca
In psychology, we know there’s two times in your life where you’re going through rapid like rapid synaptic pruning, all these different things that happen. So the first is, those first four years, is like none other. This is the age where you can raise a baby in any country in the world, and they can fluently speak the language correctly. You learn so much, you learn more in that first little bit of life than ever. The other really big part is during those early teenage years. Yeah, it’s when you are now kind of going through that same development of what is the world, but also now you’re dealing with who I am, what are thoughts, what is self consciousness. Like what is morality? What are ethics? And you’re dealing with this in a more esoteric theoretical framework. And that’s, that’s a huge part. And that’s the part where your brain is not just figuring out the bigger, like the basic questions of is the world, like, safe, which you’re doing when you’re a toddler? That’s where you get your attachment stuff. In adolescence, a lot of it is, who am I? It’s identity questions? And so that’s where, sex does have a lot to do with how we see ourselves. Yes. Right. These identity questions of do we see our bodies as good or as threatening? Do we see our bodies as a neutral, just, a message that just says that that communicates to us rather than the moral value itself? Or do we see it as something that is the way that we have worth? Right. There’s all these questions that are happening in adolescence, and that’s when we often learn about sex.
Sheila
So yeah, there’s a couple of so we’re going to walk through especially the first part of the article where they’re setting up the theoretical framework. We’re not going to walk through the second part quite as much. And then I’ll and much of what they say I really agree with, there’s a couple of things I think they didn’t mention that they should have.
So we’ll talk about that at the end as well. But let’s jump in. So I’m going to read a section and then maybe I’ll leave it to you to try and explain it.
Rebecca
Try to explain it on the fly. Okay.
Sheila
So this is the first bit where they’re talking about rewarding opportunities over sexual development. Okay. That was the headline. And they’re saying that, they’re starting the section by saying sexual pleasure at first sex is remarkably stable, like across history, across cultures, the number of women who actually enjoy sex the first time they have it versus the number of men versus it like it hasn’t changed, even though, sexual pleasure in older like in older cohorts has changed remarkably and women are enjoying sex more today, like women in their 50s are enjoying sex more today than they were like 50 years ago.
That first time hasn’t changed. Like, it’s remarkably stable. And they say this in describing the worse sex women get than men. More emphasis is often placed on women’s greater risk of punishing non-normative experiences than on their lower odds of rewarding ones.
Rebecca
So, translating when we do, people have described the fact that women enjoy sex less than men, its focus is on trauma rather than lack of orgasm.
Sheila
Right? Yes, yes. However frustrating sexual experiences are more common than ones that are overtly punishing and maybe punishing in and of themselves.
Rebecca
To me that seems obvious. Okay, women are more likely to just not have an orgasm than they are to get a like to to experience trauma in any given moment. And also not experiencing orgasm is also inherently punishing.
Sheila
Yeah. So or even if it’s not about orgasm even if it’s just arousal or pleasure like because they’re just, they’re defining for a sexual experience not only as first penis and vagina, but just like petting you know. Like or making it out.
Rebecca
Like girls just don’t always enjoy it the first time.
Sheila
Because it’s focused on him and not her. And in addition to being more pervasive than sex, that is harmful or costly, sex that is lacking in rewards may be more gendered, and this discrepancy may be larger for those with less sexual experience. Okay, so yeah, it’s not, it’s not just about the fact that women are sexually abused at higher rates than boys, which is often talked about as so.
Rebecca
And that is a good thing that it is talked about that needs to be acknowledged. But also we’ve heard from a lot of women who say like, yeah, but I don’t have any good reason for not enjoying sex. Yeah. Like and they can often be like oh so, so those other women are broken because they have a good reason that I am. Like and having a sexual experience that was not inherently rewarding is awesome that your brain takes as a punishing thing. It’s not, it’s not good. That is still a good reason for not liking sex.
Sheila
Yeah. You’re not broken. Yeah. So and then they go on to say this, this gender gap may be more reliable as negative reactions to first sex very cross-culturally for women. And they’re describing negative reactions like guilt. Etcetera. And so yeah, it’s obviously culturally dependent. Right. If you grow up in a culture that says that your greatest worth is your virginity, let’s talk about it in a minute. That’s obviously going to be greater, you know, in some cultures than others. Okay. But positive reactions or their lack don’t vary.
Rebecca
In other words girls from all cultures know if they orgasm. They know if they feel good they’re like, oh, I might feel bad about that but I want to do it again. Girls know when it feels good.
Sheila
Yes. And they say that this orgasm gap is widest at sexual debut and has been all but absent from explanations for the libido gap between women and men. Even though the orgasm gap is five times larger at first sex. Women versus men.
Rebecca
Okay, 6-12% of women will have an orgasm the first time they have sex. 62 to 84% of men will have orgasm the first time they have sexual experience.
Sheila
And it’s important to note, they say that women do not differ from men in their capacity for orgasm, but they receive fewer opportunities to achieve it in partnered contexts and no fewer perhaps like the worst is your first experience with sex. So again, women are more than capable of reaching orgasm. Now I want to talk about a part of this article that evangelicals often want to ignore. But this is research. Okay. So I’m just going to share what the data is and then talk about why it’s important, okay, that women are not less able to achieve orgasm when they first embark on sex, but less enabled to achieve it by their partners is suggested by studies of women who partner with women, while orgasm and activities that directly stimulate the clitoris rarely feature in the sexual debut narratives of heterosexual women, they are not uncommon in the stories of sexual minority women.
Rebecca
Which I would say makes complete sense. Yes, like if someone was having sex with the same anatomy, obviously you’re going to know.
Sheila
So they’re saying women need to be with women are five times as likely to achieve orgasm. They further found that women are more physically satisfied at first sex when they do debut with women, and do not differ in this respect from men who do the same.
Rebecca
As men who have their first sexual debut with women.
Sheil
Perhaps most noticeably. Notably, they showed that experience gaps between women are large and partnered sexual debut context, but nonexistent in an un partnered one implicating the partner rather than the act or enjoyment for first sex
Rebecca
That means that the experience gaps for women are so and it’s not experienced terms like how much sex have you had experiences, and what was the the phenomenological it looks like? How did you feel about it? The gap is huge in partnered sex, but not when women are masturbating versus when men are masturbating.
Sheila
Right?
Rebecca
So in essence, what it’s saying is that the difference is not that this person’s clitoris doesn’t work. Yeah. This person cannot be aroused? It is the partner that they are having sex with. Because they are able to have orgasms, they are able to enjoy sex. The same rate that men are. As soon as you have a woman having sex with a man their rates go way down. And their first sex.
Sheila
And this next part I found kind of funny. Indeed others have shown that first sex is sometimes lacking in pleasure and physical satisfaction when young men debut with men, particularly when their partner adopts an insertive role as women typically do.
Sheila
So not to get too graphic, we’re going to have to explain what this means.
Rebecca
But pretty much what it means is that when men also have their first time having sex with another man, the one who is in essence the one who is receiving the bottom. Let’s be real. Yeah. Who is being inserted the way that women are or yeah, in that role in heteronormative sex as well. They also have lower rates of enjoyment. The problem across all of these different groups is when people are having sex with men. And it’s about that person’s experience. Whenever you are having partnered sex with a man for the first time having sex, it does seem that one person will just seek out their pleasure and not give their partner an opportunity for sexual enjoyment in the same way. Yeah. And naturally, even when it’s with another man.
Sheila
Yeah. And interestingly, okay, this is why we’re getting into this conversation a little bit. And a couple of weeks into my podcast, I’ve already recorded with Jessica Jenkins about how the Romans saw sex and how they saw homosexuality as well, that is, they didn’t see homosexuality the same way we do. Homosexuality was anything on the bottom?
Rebecca
Yeah, exactly.
Sheila
So, yeah. So a man who was doing the inserting was virile.
Rebecca
He was the inserter. It was very crass and very dehumanizing the way that sex in general was seen. In those times. But yeah. No, I think that this what this shows though is that we like to see this as just a gender thing where it’s like, oh, well, women just don’t experience sex the same way as men do. Women just take longer to figure this out. Well, they don’t when they’re with other women. Yeah. And even men who are with other men have less positive experiences. Which means the problem is that there’s something about how we are socializing men that have sex that is actually causing other people to enjoy sex less.
Sheila
And so in the evangelical world, if we’re talking about heterosexual marriage, that means we need to start talking about how men are socialized to have sex. And so let’s show an example of how men are socialized to have sex. You all have heard this before. Here’s Josh Howerton.
So, dudes, you know this heading in a marriage someday when you get to her wedding day. She’s been planning this day her whole life. She got her first little wedding magazine when she was 14 years old. She put the blanket around her, acting like it was a wedding dress. She put a towel over her head. That was the veil. All the things she’s been planning this day her whole life. So here’s what you need to do. You just need to stand where she tells you to stand. Where she tells you to wear and do what she tells you to do. You’re going to make her the happiest woman in the world. Okay. Now. Applause. Now that’s applause.
Let’s see if you applaud this, ladies. When you get to his wedding night. He’s been planning this night his whole life. So what you need to do is stand where he tells you to stand, wear what he tells you to wear, and do what he tells you to do. You’re going to make him the happiest man in the world.
Sheila
So the wedding night, Becca, stand where he tells you to stand.
Rebecca
Do what he tells you to do and don’t orgasm. Well, the thing is, when we know that in general, when people are having a sexual debut with a male partner, it’s not good for them. Why is all the advice about making sure it’s good for him?
Sheila
Yeah. Like I think we need to start asking if we know. And this was my main critique of this wedding night thing when it came out and I think it was 2022 and went viral. What I was saying is he’s doubling down on two things. He’s doubling down, first of all, on the obligation sex message, which we know is destructive when women get married, believe in the obligation sex message, the chance of sexual pain disorders increase is huge.
It’s one of the big reasons that evangelical women have sexual pain disorders at twice the rate of the general population. But the other is he’s cementing this idea that sex is all for men.
Rebecca
Exactly.
Sheila
You know, at exactly the time when it’s actually women who need to learn about their bodies. It’s really easy for a guy to have an orgasm.
Rebecca
It’s also men we know need to be taught that this isn’t actually all about your pleasure. Yeah, he’s gonna get, like, he’s going to have a good time if he makes sure she also has a good time. Yeah, but the reverse is not necessarily true.
Sheila
So I want to be okay. So for a book The Marriage You Want in our survey we actually asked about the honeymoon. And so we looked specifically at couples where they had both waited for sex for marriage. All right. And we said hey and we asked all kinds of questions about orgasm. And I just wanted to tell you what we found happens on the wedding night of most couples.
Rebecca
Both are like the ones who did the event, that you did the thing you were supposed to, you waited until the wedding night. You did everything your youth group leader told you. And then this is what ends up happening.
Sheila
Yeah. So first of all, 95% of our male respondents and 64% of our female respondents had had an orgasm by any means before they got married. So presumably through masturbation, although they could have been through petting because we only asked if first intercourse was.
Rebecca
They could have been doing other things that weren’t sex. They weren’t like penetrative sex, they are still sex. But you know what I mean.
Sheila
Yeah, and 81.9% of men and 67.1% of women knew at the point where they reached adulthood that women could orgasm.
Rebecca
Good.
Sheila
So but that’s also 38% of women who didn’t. Yeah. And many of them didn’t know till after age 30. Yeah. Okay. So that’s a problem. So looking at those couples who waited for sex okay. In 41.1% of couples, neither partner brought the other to orgasm before they tried penis and vagina sex. Okay, so in 40% of couples, the first thing they did was the big one.
In 25.5% of couples, both partners had brought the other to orgasm before they tried a partner
Rebecca
Which is an easier mode to try things on. It’s good to do things slowly and do things in the natural order.
Sheila
Yes, yes. And this is what we recommend in The Good Girl’s Guide to Great Sex and Good Guys Guide to Great Sex.
Rebecca
Get married, fool around, don’t go straight to like sex.
Sheila
Yeah, learn. Learn about arousal. Learn about her orgasm before you actually try some vagina sex. Okay. In 24.9% of couples, only the husband had been brought to orgasm by his partner.
Rebecca
Yeah, this is so funny, because then it means, like, okay, so you haven’t had sex yet. You’ve given him a hand job. Yeah, but, like, she hasn’t gotten anything.
Sheila
In 8.5% of couples only the wife had been brought to orgasm. Okay, so that means that 50.4% of men had been brought to orgasm by their spouse before penetrative sex, but only 34.1% of women had. Yeah. All right. Then when we look at the first time that they have sex, which could also include other things than just penetration, okay, 14.2% of couples both partners climaxed, 11.6% of couples neither did and 1.2% of couples only the wife and 73% only the husband.
Rebecca
Yeah. Exactly.
Sheila
So break that down. And 87.3% of men, but only 15.4% of women reached orgasm through any form of stimulation during the first encounter involving intercourse. Yeah, okay. So that’s exactly what this is saying.
Rebecca
Yeah. Which is exactly what this is finding. So men tend to have a good time. And not every single individual. Sure. But when we’re looking at trends, men are fine. Women are being left behind. Men are fine but their partners are being left behind.
Sheila
And a lot of this is because we are stressing what men want over what women want. Now they have, they have a cute little graph. I’ll show you some of the graphs they have in this graph. We’re going to put it on the screen. If you’re watching on YouTube.
Rebecca
I am going to describe what you’re seeing. Yeah. What they were looking at was the quality of sex over the reproductive life course of people in their framework. When we’re looking at the trajectories of sexual risk and with sexual reward. Okay. And corresponding to some expected cost and benefit of sex. So in essence what they found is in early to late adolescence like so when you’re a teenager, right. Like when you’re a kid. The risks are really high.
Sheila
First of all you’ve obviously you’ve got the major risk of pregnancy, but there’s also higher risk of I think people forget that teenage relationships have huge rates of abuse.
Rebecca
Huge rates of abuse and assault. Yeah.
Sheila
Huge rates of coercion.
Rebecca
Really confusing cause you are both kids. It’s not the same as when you’re a fully fledged adult who actually likes impulse control and is choosing to do this. Like sometimes your 14 year old’s like. You look at 14 year olds – that’s a baby. Like, yes, it’s really complex and complicated. And so often you have these really negative or weird experiences you don’t even know what to call them. And it’s a whole. So they have higher rates of coercion like there’s a lot more risks even if we know from multiple studies that engaging in sexual experiences when you are young has a very higher, impact on your mental health. Yeah, it has, compared to other, other times of your life, like even consensual sexual activity at age 13. Super bad for you. Not great. You’re not going to find an article where it’s like, yeah, 13 year olds should be making out behind the school and doing heavy petting and having sex. No, because it’s not there’s a lot of mental health repercussions in there because you’re in that identity formation phase. And so then right then you get caught up in this person who’s outside of you and then you inevitably break up seven weeks later. And that was the longest relationship your school has ever seen in that.
Sheila
Right?
Rebecca
Right. Like this whole thing happens anyway. So the graph is that the risk is super, high rewards are super low in early to late adolescence. And then the rewards kind of like go up as
you get closer to adulthood. And then at some point like older adolescents so 18-24 or emerging adulthood, the risks finally go to be lesser than the rewards. But it takes a long time. And then in your earlier middle adulthood, the risks are lower than the rewards because, like, if you accidentally get pregnant at 31, like, well, congrats. Like, that’s what I want to do at 31.
Sheila
And people tend to be in more stable relationships. So they’ve got less abuse or coercion.
Rebecca
You are older, you know more sexual, you know more information. You know, how to protect yourself from STIs. You might be like, you’re settled in a good relationship, more likely, like you’re making choices that are truly yours. Rather than you’re a kid figuring things out, right? Yeah. So in essence, what they’re finding here is that, like, the expected benefits of sex are often completely missing. In a lot of the years where we have a lot of risks, but we’re also creating a lot of our internal identities around sex.
Sheila
Yeah. And so for boys, this isn’t necessarily true, boys do not face the same risks with sex that girls do. And boys have way more rewards. And so when we’re looking at libido differences, like 30 years later after adolescence, what they’re trying to build up is what they’re trying to suggest in this article is that maybe that’s a natural outcome of these early experiences with sex. Yeah. And again, we’re not just talking about penetrative sex. We’re talking about exposure to sex, sexual experiences, masturbation, all of it. Okay, I want to speak of negative associations with sex, I want to play a clip from Pastor Scott Anderson. We’ve been picking on Arizona pastors a lot. I don’t know how this happens. It’s not intentional. But here he is I think Living Church, Living Something Church in Mesa, Arizona. And I’ll just let it speak for itself, okay? He is doing a stitch. So the first voice you’re going to hear is
Rebecca
Alex from The Call Me Daddy podcast.
Sheila
Yeah. And he’s going to respond to it.
Alex
A girl has a list of the guys she’s ever been with. I have mine written in a book somewhere, and then I also think I have one in my notes app. It’s fun. It’s life. Okay. I remember the men that have been inside of me and I have a husband and that’s okay. Like, I had a past when I was with them I didn’t know my husband existed
Pastor Scott Anderson
A horrible thing to be out on the internet. I don’t even know what kind of whole like mentality that is. And this is what our teenagers are watching number one, don’t allow your teenage daughters and girls and boys to have social media and to be able to get this garbage into their mind. My daughter has a list and I think nobody is on her list when she gets married, because I knew she’ll know. She knows that her future husband exists, and the greatest gift that she can give him is her virginity. That’s the best gift. And that has to be the message from my house. Has to be the message of the family that we wait. You know how many problems that you solve for teenagers who get overly involved in their emotions because they allowed sex at 14, 15, 16 years old into their relationships.
Now they’re overly connected for something that was meant to be a lifetime because parents have bought into this culture. What do you do? I know what you do. You do everything that you can. Every voice that you have in her life, from the time that she can remember, as we wait, we save ourselves. This is the greatest gift that you can give your future husband. That is the thing that we have to make sure that we’re putting into our daughters is something that comes from the mom and dad. It comes from the home, because this is what’s going to give her a great life.
Sheila
Becca, did you know when you were married that the best gift you could give your husband was your virginity?
Rebecca
I think that also makes me laugh about this. Is that then what you just peak on your wedding night and it just goes downhill from there? Okay, baby. You got it.
Sheila
Yeah. It’s not.
Rebecca
Now you’ve got sloppy seconds, but at least it was yours, like that’s what it implies. And it’s so ridiculous. It’s like we know that you are in love with a person. Your wife’s vagina is not a comic book. You know what I mean? Like, it’s not like, oh, mint condition. It doesn’t make any difference. It’s like, yeah, it’s ridiculous. And anyone who has been married actually. But here’s the thing with all these stats that we’ve done. And knowing how bad a lot of people’s sex lives are and knowing from our research how bad it seems a lot of these pastors and authors sex lives are, it may very well be that it felt like the peak. Yeah. Because it was the first time and it was always complicated after that.
Sheila
Yeah. For the pastor, it was the best.
Rebecca
I do wonder how many of these people, like, that’s the best thing you can possibly do, because it felt like a rush, like, oh, I took someone’s virginity because they all have a conquest mindset for sex. They don’t have a relational mindset for sex. They have a conquest mindset for sex. Yeah, maybe that is the rush for them. Maybe that was the reward. Maybe they were like, that actually is the best ever. Because they don’t understand what sex actually can be like. You know, and they’re in there. They see this reward as being able to conquer their wife. Whereas that’s never been what it’s meant to be. It’s about sharing something together. And I will say, like, listen, I am not arguing with this man that a 14 year old should be listening to the Call Me Daddy podcast. No. I’m like, no, guys.
We can all be reasonable here. But the answer isn’t then from the minute that she’s old enough, everything she hears is we wait and I’m like, oh dear. Yeah that is unnecessary.
Sheila
Well, I just find it so amazing as you girls got older and you got ready to get married, I realized, there were things I cared about so much more. I care about it. Is he going to be safe for you? Is he going to be? Like, like the things that you think are important? It’s not that they’re not. It’s just that they come down so much in terms of where you would place them, because safety and flourishing and well-being are so much higher.
Rebecca
And my thing to do is, and I’ve said this before the discussion people have the how like you have a future husband out there and you know he says or like I am someone who is teaching who is well, I mean, my children are seven and five, but I’m someone who’s going to be teaching her children to have a chaste life. And we can have a conversation about what that means, right? It does not mean save your kiss for your wedding day, for pity’s sake. Like when I was growing up. But I am someone who is very chaste, I am someone who doesn’t believe in, like you know, having pornography in my marriage. Like I am a very chaste person. I expect my children to also have chaste lives. I do believe that there is chastity as a part of the Christian life, but we can argue about what that means, what it doesn’t mean is seeing your virginity as a gift. That’s disgusting. Even if you are a virgin when you get married, your virginity is not a gift. Like, that’s what I feel very strongly about.
Sheila
Well, and the other thing is, why are we making this gender like, even if he believes that the virginity is a gift? Yeah. Why is it only hers? Like, there’s nothing in Scripture that says that only she has to be a virgin. And the fact that they’ll say that he says her virginity and that it’s all about her as opposed to both of them, is really telling to me.
Rebecca
And I get back to this because it sees sex as something men take from women. Yeah. But additionally we hear from so many people who you know like I said like I’m saying that because I know people get mad at me and they always say, oh are you saying that this is okay, get this. And I get the emails and I ignore them because I don’t actually think that that question warrants a response. Yeah, you can figure this out for yourself, but when I hear the mentality that, like the podcast host Alex has, versus the mentality of people who message us who are ripped apart because their spouse had sex with someone before they met each other, and they are devastated and like having to seek out therapy for this. And yeah, I actually think that that one is healthier. The idea that this isn’t a big deal. Yeah. If you’re going to choose one, one is not destroying people’s lives. In the same way, because you can be chaste and say, today I make different decisions, but all the past, that doesn’t matter. You can have that mentality. You know, like you can. Yeah. And again, I’m not saying that I cosign Alex’s personal sexual ethic. No, that’s not what I’m saying. But what I’m saying is we get so many messed up people who hear what this pastor is saying, and they believe this pastor and it’s ruining their perfectly happy marriages because that person cannot get over something that genuinely does not matter. I’m saying that they’re not bringing it into their relationship, it is your responsibility to get over it. Yeah, like flat out. And I actually believe it is a form of emotional abuse to hold that over someone’s head because someone cannot be responsible for choices that they made in the past before they knew you, when you were not in a relationship.
Sheila
Yeah. Now, of course, if that person is comparing you, that’s a different story. But we’re talking about a woman or a man, a spouse who is like, it was in my past. I don’t even think about it. I chose you like, then why are you torturing them?
Rebecca
Yes. Like that actually is abusive. Yeah, I am flat out. I feel very strongly about that. If it’s something like well, it was 20 years ago when he cheated on me. No no no no, that’s different. You can deal with that. Yeah. Like if it’s like he’s 16 with his high school girlfriend and you guys met at 24. Like if you bring that up over and over. I just don’t see how that’s not severely psychologically damaging to your partner. So I just feel very strongly about that. And that’s why I really don’t like what this guy is. Yeah. Because he’s saying this is the worst thing ever. And I’m like, you’re destroying marriage.
Sheila
Yes. And if you want to talk to your children differently. So if you want to teach them differently, we have a way for you to do that. So we created a course called The Whole Story. Rebecca and my younger daughter Katie do the girls side of it. Rebecca’s husband, Connor, and Daniel Barrows, who was a medical student at the time, do the boys. Do the boys, version. And we have the younger version for 10 to 12 year olds, the older version for 13 to 16 year olds. And we’re going to put it on sale just for this podcast discussion. So there is a link in the podcast notes, use the Coupon Code podcast to get 25% off. And I think we’re going to extend that until, probably next Thursday. Next podcast. Yes. So that gives you a whole week to hear this podcast and go and get the Whole Story. It’s a lifetime access. So if we ever update it, we did a major recall, two years ago. Yeah. To incorporate all of the data that we got from our survey of girls like for She Deserves Better. And we included a lot of the stuff that they’re actually talking about in this article about how important it is for women to understand that they can orgasm too.
Rebecca
And they talk to you as a parent about how do we talk about this in an age appropriate way? Yeah. Right. Yeah. And, a lot of it is about how do you have those conversations with your kid to figure out what are your personal sexual boundaries, but more importantly, why you understand not just that this is a rule that if you break it, you’re broken. But this is a principle by which we are going to live our lives. And this is how it works out in this particular area. Yeah, that’s a conversation you can have with your kids. Coupon code podcast 25% off only for this week. So if the next podcast is out, you’re too late. But you can get on our mailing list so if we do sales like this, you hear about it. And our mailing list link is also in the description.
Sheila
Yes. So there you go. All right. I want to get to the next section, which is interesting. How we come to describe good sex. I was so happy with this section because I’ve been talking about this and it came out. So here’s what they say. Because pleasure is relatively scarce in women’s earliest sexual encounters, perhaps they come not to expect it from sex, nor even to consider its absence a deprivation. So, in other words, women don’t even expect to feel good during sex.
Rebecca
And so they don’t even say sex is bad when they don’t feel good.
Sheila
Indeed, by the time they reach adulthood, women may match or surpass men in their satisfaction with sex, but they differ in their threshold for it. That is, men often include pleasure and orgasm in their definitions of satisfying sex. Yet women define satisfying sex merely as sex that is free of pain and degradation.
Rebecca
Yeah.
Sheila
You know, so, so bad sex for women is sex where I felt degraded. I had a lot of pain. I felt threatened, I felt scared, bad sex for men. Is it just not hot enough, you know? And those are very different things. And so for women, it’s like I have satisfying sex if the negative stuff isn’t there.
Rebecca
Yeah, it’s satisfying because it was actually satisfying.
Sheila
And then they go on to say alternatively women might lower their standard for satisfying sex each time sex fails to please such that the worse sex they get becomes less visible over time, both to themselves and to sexologists. Should this be the case? The satisfaction gap at first sex may not just be the largest one on record, but the one least biased by repeated and cumulative experience of orgasm inequality and I want this to be like the most important part is. That gets to me, because what they’re saying is that when surveys ask women whether sex is good or not, right, it almost universally finds that first sex is bad.
Rebecca
Because when women say it, it gets better. Yeah. And when they say that same sex life is fine, but what they’re saying is. But is it like, yeah. But is it just because they lowered their standards so much that like the first time was terrible. But now at least it doesn’t hurt anymore. Yeah, yeah, but it’s not that it’s good. I’m saying that it doesn’t mean that it’s good though, honey.nLike you can have more.
Sheila
Yeah. And then they go on to. Indeed if the standard for satisfying sex diverges for women in men as gendered experience of orgasm accumulates. So the longer you go on where he orgasms and she doesn’t, satisfaction at first sex may offer a relatively clean developmental snapshot, a moment when satisfaction reflects felt sexual pleasure for each gender rather than deeply ingrained pleasure disparities and gendered expectations for achieving it. For this reason, satisfaction at sexual debut may offer the most interpretable and equitable metric of sexual satisfaction that can be compared across genders. So. So we can’t actually know if we look at surveys of adults, is what they’re saying, because women are so accustomed to the bar being like on the ground. I want you to remember what happened. I think it was about two months ago. There was a new study out that got like it went in the Atlantic. It went all over claiming that evangelicals had the best sex. The Christians had the best sex because it was looking at Catholics primarily, by the Institute of Family Studies. And they did this survey. We critiqued it a lot on my Substack, and you and I did a Friday round up about it. So for those of you who don’t know who listen to the podcast, we kind of have a mini podcast on Fridays that’s just on YouTube and it’s totally unscripted.
Rebecca
Yeah we don’t edit it or anything either. So it’s a little bit more like us free form.
Sheila
Yeah. And we just took this study apart, so we’ll put a link to that. I think it was Keith and I did it actually. So I think your dad and I did it.
Rebecca
And I did a newsletter on it that week
Sheila
So we’ll put a link to that Friday roundup and to my Substack article looking at it. But what this study asked was how often you have sex. That’s it. It didn’t ask anything else.
It asked how you felt about your marriage, but it didn’t ask how you felt about sex and it was because people had more frequent sex. They said therefore their sex lives are better. And so we were kind of going ballistic about that. Lisa Stoddard Reeves, who follows us on Facebook, she’s a researcher herself. We have many conversations. Lisa and I go back and forth. She wrote a big article about this, which I’m also going to put in the podcast notes. But I want to read you some of her takes on this about the IFS study. The authors provide no corresponding comparison of sexual desire and whether sex is mutually wanted. Orgasm in physical pleasure, women’s ability to decline sex without negative consequences where their partner’s sexual needs are treated as equally important, and sexual satisfaction independent of frequency. So they did not ask about orgasm. They did not ask about any of those things. And then she had this beautiful chart which we put on the screen right where it said. So. The evidence that they had for this study was that religious married couples report more frequent sex. What that reasonably tells us is that religious participation is associated with frequency. Yes. What it cannot tell us is if religion produces greater sexual satisfaction.
Rebecca
Absolutely. We might just be having more bad sex.
Sheila
Right. And conservative wives politically report more weekly sex than liberal wives. What that can say is that there is an ideological difference in reported behavior. What it cannot say is that conservative wives experience more sexual pleasure.
Rebecca
I would argue a lot of times if you’re, conservatives are more likely to have a stay at home wife situation that liberals are, so you may be, just not home as often at the same time. What if you’re both working shift work? You could also have it be that, it might be that you’re conservatives are more likely to believe things about husband and wife roles, and so they’re more likely to have sex they don’t want to have versus more, liberal ideological women. Yeah. There’s a lot of explanations that are not the sex is better.
Sheila
Right. And but what she goes on to say, I’ll just read this one paragraph, our religious women having more sex because their marriages are more sexually fulfilling, or because they have been taught that being a good wife includes making themselves sexually available? It would be a mistake to assume the second explanation, but it is equally mistaken to assume the first. The research as presented does not adjudicate between them, and that is a significant omission in an article specifically celebrating religious marital sexuality.
Rebecca
Yes. Exactly.
00:42:17:03 – 00:42:36:11
Speaker 2
So here and this is what I was saying, is like there can be major rose colored glasses, like women can be saying, yes, I have good sex now, or yes, I like my sex life. But if women are defining good sex by not having pain or degradation and their husband being satisfied.
And their husbands being satisfied, which again, the survey, the article does go on to talk about that, then how do we actually know whether women’s satisfaction, you know, really is on par with men’s later on? Like it could be that there’s a major gap there too. And that’s some of the things that we tried to tease out in our surveys. And I think we did a much better job of it because we yeah, we didn’t just ask, but self-report. Interestingly, one thing that we did find, and I talked about this in my Substack article, is there is a rose colored glasses phenomenon where the more that you agree that the husband is the head of the wife and is an authority, the less bothered you are by not orgasming.
Rebecca
Interesting
Sheila
So yeah. You just because you expect things to be about him. Exactly. All right. And I want to show some first some proof of this. We want to bring back Josh Harrison. And for this one his wife is Jana. And this is a little bit of a longer clip, but I want to listen to it because it’s so typical of how sex advice is given in evangelical churches. Okay, so hang on, this is a little awkward. Not my fault. Let’s listen in
Jana
Sex is important and. And you need to make sure you’re having more of it.
Josh
Somebody during the early stages of marriage. There was, early in ministry. I asked the pastor, like, man, I don’t know how to like, I don’t know how to discipline people in this area what should I say. And he said, well, in every church, here’s the deal. You’re single people need to be having less sex and you’re married people need to be having more.There you go. That’s what you need to help them figure out. Go ahead.
Jana
Okay. So if you want to see some ripple effects in your marriage, first, I’d say make him feel wanted. So, start desiring him. Pursuing him? Initiate sex with your husband. Just like the lady in Psalms. It’s almost like she gives us an example. So if you do, this is going to blow his mind.
Josh
That’s incredible.
Josh
So this is your superpower, right? So sex builds intimacy, and it’s just not. It’s not just a physical thing. I think people think it’s just a physical thing, but it’s not. It needs a powerful emotional need. It does for women. But I mean, it really does for men. So feeling wanted in this way gives a man confidence and a sense of well-being, being in every other area of his life. So, I’m just going to say this. Yeah. So the next time he has a big thing going on at work, he has a big meeting or something he’s nervous about, you know what to do. No confidence to walk into that meeting. So. And then just women need to remember that emotional intimacy for them is going to lead to physical intimacy. But for him, physical intimacy leads him to emotional intimacy. And so it’s kind of like we both need to be playing our parts and doing what we need to be doing for the other. And then you’re going to improve your intimacy with women.
Sheila
All right. The reason I said it was awkward was because Jana just doesn’t want to be there.
Rebecca
I know, this is one of my soap boxes. We need to stop expecting pastors to talk about sex because inevitably they drag their wives in who did not sign up for this job, did not want this job. And now they have to talk about their personal sex lives because that’s all pastors are trained to talk about because they don’t have any actual training in this area. Yeah, I think that it’s incredible, it’s incredibly coercive and it’s not fair. Yeah, yeah, the husbands either, but the men like Josh are raring at the bit to talk about their sex lives. The average pastor also, though, does not want to. And when the congregation pressures them to talk about sex like that, it usually ends up that they accidentally say more than they wanted.
And I find it all very exploitative of pastors to expect them to talk about sex.
Sheila
It’s and it’s just, it’s just icky. But also look at the advice that they’re giving. It is entirely about how to make sex fun and good for him. Even though what we have shown in this article shows and we have repeatedly shown in all of our data. Men are not the ones who have a problem enjoying sex. Women are the ones who have a problem enjoying sex. And yet when you have the opportunity to talk about sex, do they say to men, hey, love your wife like your own body? That means that she needs to feel good with sex or even better than you do. So even though the Bible tells men to love their wives as their own bodies, that means that she should be feeling as good as you do, if not better. What do they emphasize? Make sure you give them a lot of sex that he really likes. That’s going to help him handle his work, stress and all of this. And who is the one who really needs that message? Like the message is so lopsided and distorted. And if they really cared about good sex lives, they would stop telling women to have more sex, and they would start telling men how to make sex good for their wives, because again, I’m going to name five things, okay? This is what we found in our surveys and all of our surveys that back this up.
When women report high marital satisfaction, when they frequently reach orgasm during sex, when they feel connected during sex, so they don’t feel dehumanized in any way, when there’s no porn use in the marriage and when there’s no sexual dysfunction, she wants sex, there’s no problem with frequency. And so instead of talking about how we get women to have more sex, let’s talk about if sex isn’t happening. Let’s show some curiosity, not judgment, Ted Lasso curiosity, not judgment. And let’s ask which of those five things is not happening.
Rebecca
Exactly.
Sheila
All right. Let’s go on. Okay. Next point, women get the worst sex when it may be the most formative. So they talk about three different phases of the sexual cycle. They talk about wanting, which is desire. Right? They talk about liking, which is pleasure. But then they also talk about learning. And this is what a lot of people miss, is that there is a learning curve for sex and that capacity for learning is actually greatest in adolescence and in emerging adulthood, because that’s when the brain is changing and everything. And so and so what happens in these early years is that you can learn stuff about sex that you don’t want to learn.
Rebecca
You’re a sponge. And so they say this like, we know that the teenagers in early adulthood years, they’re called your formative years.
Sheila
Yeah, yeah. And so they say we propose that sexual learning in adolescence engages these experience expectant systems and that such learning plays a formative role in establishing adult patterns of sexual desire and behavior in context where adolescents encounter greater sexual adversity, whether through atypical like punishing exposures or deprivation of expected ie rewarded ones, they may experience profound and enduring consequences across the neuropsychological systems governing sexual interest. And that’s really their primary thesis in the whole paper, which is when the brain forms. And if you’re not getting any rewards and you’re getting a lot of punishment, then that is going to affect your neuro, what do they say your neuropsychological systems governing sexual interests.
Rebecca
And again this doesn’t mean that you need to be having sex at 14 or 15. That’s not what it means. But I remember when I read this, what makes me think, what makes me think about is like even just how many of us in purity culture, we’re reading so many books about waiting for sex until marriage. I have scary stories of girls getting pregnant at 14, or getting STIs or, you know, getting cheated on, or all these awful things that could happen if you had sex. And we also weren’t allowed to read very sweet romance novels.
Like, how much of it is that like, we’re so you’re allowed to watch movies that have rape in them because that’s bad. But you’re not allowed to watch them having sex in them. Right?
I think I’m not saying all of these things are things you should do or not, but it’s, this is the question of balance right. Your child and you I let’s, let’s talk about you as a kid as a, like a 14 year old kid. Right. Like, were you allowed to have sexual feelings without shame? Because that’s a part of sexual development is having those butterflies and, you know, being sexually curious in a safe way. And that to me would include, like, reading a book that’s maybe got like, oh my goodness, they made out for a little bit longer than the other books I’ve read before. Right, I am not talking about full smut. Were you only allowed to read stories about girls whose lives are ruined because they had sex at 14? Right. as if you were someone who experienced a lot of discussions about things like the modesty message. Were you allowed to enjoy your body? Right. Like were you allowed to just feel confident in yourself, or were you constantly cut down in that area and told you were a threat?
Sheila
Well, do you remember? In She Deserves Better one of the things we found is that how you felt about your period in adolescence was highly correlated with self-esteem later and highly correlated even with things like, marrying an abuser. And it’s not because how you feel about your period makes you marry an abuser. There’s a deeper thing about self-esteem, etc.
Rebecca
In the kind of family that causes a lot of shame and secrecy around these things. Then you weren’t as educated to recognize that this person wasn’t actually healthy because you weren’t allowed to talk about these things?
Sheila
Yeah, but think about that. So the first time that you hear about sex, okay, is also when you’re hearing about your period and then you’re given the message, but don’t ever have sex because now you can get pregnant.
Rebecca
Because you have a most precious gift. And if you ever give it away, then you’ll be tied to that person for the rest of your life.
Sheila
So it’s a totally negative message. And that’s why in the Whole Story, we made a deliberate decision to separate the messages about like the threatening messages like, don’t. Well, we never really gave in to threats but honestly about risks and stuff but like for the older kids. But in the younger ones when we’re just explaining what sex is, what your period is, we’re not like, but don’t ever have sex and don’t ever do this because they’re ten, right?
Rebecca
Like, I know this is kind of weird and don’t worry, you don’t have to worry about this right now. This is not for kids. Not it’s yeah, it’s a sin. And yeah. So you will be irrevocably tied.
Sheila
Like we did, we did Passport to Purity. And we talked about this a lot when we were releasing the Whole Story as we did Passport to Purity by Family Life. You and I. I did not do it with Katie because it was such a disaster with you. So you were my guinea pig. And like, literally as soon as you hear about sex, which freaks you out to begin with, right? You’re given all of these things about how your body is a temptation to boys, and you need to promise to keep it hidden.
Rebecca
And every single boy you ever meet will want to have sex with you.
Sheila
And these messages happening, happening around adolescence, when your brain is so plastic, have long term repercussions. Because when we’re talking about positive experiences with sexuality, we’re not just talking about sex, we’re also talking about all these messages that happen in adolescence. So it’s so important. What they were talking about was how abuse that happens around adolescence really has big effects long term. And we’ve known that on adult sexuality, but it’s more than just abuse. So we wrote a paper, well, I’m not an author on it, but you and Joanna are coauthors, along with Nicole Gallego, who was the main author using our data set for she deserves Better, a peer reviewed paper, and I’ll put a link in the podcast notes for that, too.
But I want to just read a paragraph from it. Okay.
Descriptive analysis of sexual abuse variables found that 18.7% of total sample participants had experienced sexual harassment or unwanted sexual attention in church, while a minor, compared to 5.23% while an adult. Overall, 76% of participants had never had an experience of sexual harassment at church. The overall rate of sexual abuse within the sample, not limited to abuse occurring in a church setting, was 31.38%, so teenagers are like more than three times as likely to be sexually harassed and assaulted in church situations as adults are.
Rebecca
And a lot of it is from other teenagers in the church
Sheila
And what this paper argues is that and what our stats found is that this is more likely to happen in churches that teach the modesty message. So in churches that double down on negative, negative teachings around sex, so threatening one’s punishing one’s right, you need to not be a stumbling block for the boys around you.
Rebecca
Girls that dress immodestly are worse than girls who don’t.
Sheila
Yeah. So churches that double down on those see higher rates of sexual harassment and assault among girls. And so that’s, that’s really scary. And that impacts girls long term. Think about how the church is always arguing about how we shouldn’t sexualize children in the world, sexualized as children. That’s kind of what Scott Anderson was doing on that. Right. But as soon as the church starts telling girls they need to cover up so the adult men don’t lust after them, the church is doing way more sexualizing of those girls.
Rebecca
And stop saying from the minute that they can remember the messages – we wait, you’re sexualizing that child then. Yeah like you like if you are constantly if you are creating your child’s identity about their sexual experiences, you are sexualizing that child far more than the world is trying to. Yeah. That was a really big wake up call for me as we’re doing all this research, realizing every accusation is a confession. I’m like, oh, the world’s going to sexualize your kids. Well, the vast majority of the sexualization that I experienced as a child is from Baptist churches. Yeah. Like, that’s actually the truth of it. Like, obviously I experienced it from our culture. Sure. Absolutely. But when I think about the messages that I experienced about sex, the majority came from the church, right. And the places where I was sexualized, most were church places.
Sheila
But think about what sexualization means, too. So let’s say that an 11 year old girl and you know, you’re going over what sex means, what sex is, she probably already knows, but you’re going over in more detail, you’re going over her period, etc.. And now you set her down and you say, now I need you to pledge to me to never do that with a boy until you’re married. At that moment, she is grossed out. And so when you tell her you need to pledge not to do it, she’s thinking, you think I want to do this disgusting thing? And that’s a weird feeling. As a kid, I don’t know if you can remember, like, think back to what you felt when you were ten or 11 or 12. Like, I remember, being about 11 and I got one of those. And my days, it was phone calls. You don’t get it as much anymore. But, you know, someone calls and says something really sexually degrading to you because, yeah, a little kid picked up and I was so grossed out. It leaves you feeling so icky, right? Because it’s like, that man saw me in this way and thought, I liked it. Something that I thought was disgusting, thought I liked it, and that was just like, that is sexualizing me. That’s totally grossing you out.
Rebecca
On the other hand, We hear from a lot of girls who, like they were 12 and they were very sexually curious. And then they hear how bad it is and how awful it sounds. Good girls don’t want this. And like, oh, so am I a terrible person then? And then it screws them up that way too. Whereas you can have another message that’s very developmentally appropriate. It’s like when we attach identity and obsess over sex with children, we are sexualizing them. Giving children information is not sexualizing, just explaining, oh, this is what sperm is, this is what an egg is, this is what the clitoris is, this is what an erection is. That’s not sexualizing your kid. But being like this is what an erection is and then having a weird conversation about boners that is not informative but is just talking about, you know, adding weird spiritual stuff to it. This is how the devil gets at you. And every time you have this like that actually now flits into sexualizing it. Yeah. It’s like we are not having, we are not going to, put and project a sexual identity onto a minor. We are not doing that. And that does include the Every Young Man’s Battle stuff that. Yeah, the modesty messages that do include those kinds of you can have honest conversations with kids where you’re not using fear tactics and speaking an identity over them.
Sheila
Almost all evangelical literature up to this point that’s been sex ed has done that. It is spoken of an identity over them like this is something that you’re going to want to do. And Every Young Man’s Battle was awful for this. Like it basically described all young men as monsters. And so many young men who read it felt like that.
Rebecca
Exactly and again, the difference between saying, hey, here are the risks associated with sex. Here’s what the Bible says sex is about. Here’s what our family believes, and here’s what I want for you in your life – that’s information. Your virginity is your most precious gift. And someday you’ll get married and you’re going to offer that gift to your husband and on the wedding night he’ll be so happy. He goes, yeah. So you’re thinking, man, I’m so happy some day with that pretty little precious gift. Like that’s different, don’t do that Scott. Take it and shove it. Stop it. It’s creepy. You’re way creepier than any like I like this thing is the way that woman who he’s critiquing talked about kids is less creepy than how he talks about kids. That’s all I’m saying.
Sheila
All right. Next section. Bio psychosocial mechanisms linking developmental opportunities and outcomes.
Rebecca
Bio psychosocial as someone who does psychology it’s one of my favorite words cause it’s a bit of everything. It’s like this, is it this, is it that? It was not, we don’t know. It’s everything. Every time I see psychosocial I’m like was there a need for these three disciplines to be as separated.
Sheila
Okay. So what they’re saying is adolescence is a time of developing self narrative and differentiation from parents and new identity. So sex has the worst returns for women, right? When their bio psychosocial is primed to learn from it. Yes. Okay. And so, so like, and we’ll put this on the graph. This new graph up on the.
Rebecca
So sorry for those who only listen to it. This one is a little bit too complicated for me to explain.
Sheila
But what they’re saying is like there’s huge gender differences in, in, in what you’re learning about sex in early adolescence and in quality of sex. And then that really goes down as soon as you hit early to middle adulthood.
Rebecca
Gender differences. So when you’re looking at this graph, this is not about, like this, this, this, this graph is showing the difference in experience between men and women, ordinary and boys and girls at each of these ages. So when you’re really young, the size of the gender differences in like in essence the learning potential is huge. And as you get older it’s like oh there’s all kinds of the gender difference isn’t nearly as big. And so that’s the problem.
Yeah the difference is the biggest when we’re learning about sex.
Sheila
And when it often solidifies things long term. So they say that women have a higher capacity for sexual aptitude and pleasure learning and doing things differently. But all of this is mediated by pleasure they’ve already experienced or not experienced. So women have a huge aptitude for learning and doing things differently, for learning about sexual pleasure. But that aptitude is mediated by what you’ve already experienced. And so what you’ve already experienced is really bad. Or you see, sex is really bad. It’s going to be a lot harder.
Rebecca
Now, the good news is what this doesn’t find, and what studies do not find is that if it’s been bad for them even for decades, you can’t learn. No, that’s not at all. And what often helps is knowing how you got there because you can identify it and be like, oh, this is just my brain in a rut because of high punishment and low pleasure for years. Yeah. So if you’re listening to this and you’re like Sheila or Rebecca or someone who has not had an orgasm in 15 years, this is depressing. This is not saying things won’t change. This is not saying, oh, you missed your shot. This is not saying that. What this is saying is that there’s a reason it’s been hard and that you have had an outsized amount of punishment and an undersized amount of pleasure. And if we’re going to fix that, we have to fix that, can we? Because the issue isn’t just you, it’s figuring out how we swap that? Yeah. How do we get rid of the punishment and increase the pleasure? Yeah. Okay. So I just want to put that out there. So I’m like, I can just see some of our listeners being I am just so depressed.
Sheila
There’s this other section and I think of everything that we’re going to get emails on. It’s going to be this section okay. And you’re probably gonna be mad at me for even mentioning it, but it is in the study. And I just think it’s important to mention, so they’re talking about some of the other things that can mediate how girls learn about pleasure. And one of the things that they’re hypothesizing is that the way that we medicate girls, teenage girls, can be a problem because they say that in the United States, the pill is the leading form of contraception among girls and women, 15 to 19, who are sexually active. Okay, so 56% of girls 15 to 19 were sexually active. Yeah. All right. And hormonal contraceptives are the most commonly prescribed medication for Canadian girls and women aged 12 to 19, followed by antidepressants. But there hasn’t been any research on the implications for sexual learning around this. So if your first experience with sex is also when you’re on medication, that decreases testosterone and some of the hormone levels that are associated with sexual pleasure, that might be a problem. And, you know, and we just need to think about this.
Rebecca
It becomes a risk assessment. Right. Because girls are on this because they’re sexually experienced. Right? Right. And it’s like, don’t get pregnant. Please. Yes. Like, yeah. We are not saying that you’re a bad mom if you have a daughter who is having sex and you’re putting her on the pill, please put her on the pill. Yeah, because right now there is not an alternative that is actually safe for teenagers because it was like, oh, they just kind of. Some say just use condoms. They’re teenagers. Yeah. You do not rely on condoms as a teenager. No, you do not. Though you still need to use a condom because of STI’s.
Sheila
And again we don’t want teenagers having sex. We’re just saying if your 16-17 year old is anyway, don’t let them get pregnant.
Rebecca
We’re just I’m just saying that, like, what this study is not saying is teenagers should not be on the pill. What we are saying is we need to have studies on whether the side effects of antidepressants, the pill or whether there are alternatives that can do the same thing. These negative effects. Also, the question is, why is it always girls that are going on these things, like we know that there are medications that work for men. They just don’t put them out because they have side effects. Well, the girls have side effects too.
Sheila
I really want to have that woman who wrote, Ejaculate Responsibly. That is such a good book. It’s short. And anyway, we really want to talk about it one time. Yeah.
Rebecca
How was the question like so so anti-depressants have been linked to reduction in testosterone too they say. Yeah. Beginning in adolescence twice as many women are placed on them as men. Additionally I will say that is not mentioned here. Twice as many women will have depression than men. Yeah. So it’s like this. This isn’t one of those things where it’s like girls are medicated than men. Additionally what is not mentioned here is that twice as many women will have depression than men in adolescence. So it’s like this isn’t one of those things that girls are more medicated than men as much as girls experience more internalizing like that.
Sheila
But I think it is valid. Like if you think about the majority of evangelical women that I’ve spoken to go on the pill before their wedding. And so women who have never had sex, who are waiting for the wedding, like, go on the pill because then they can guarantee they’re not going to have their period on their wedding, which is a huge deal. You know, you’ve waited and and I’m not saying that it’s really bad.
Rebecca
As someone who had bad periods, I also didn’t want to have my period at my wedding. I wanted to enjoy the day.
Sheila
Like obviously obviously like no one wants that. Right. But is that affecting us because your first experience with sex like that and the research on this is really, varied like mixed. We’ve done a lot of looking at some of the journal articles about whether the pill actually reduces libido, but they’re looking at women as a whole. They’re not looking at this learning phase, which is what this article is talking about.
Rebecca
For a lot of women, it might be that like because we have hormonal fluctuations throughout our lives, right. Like when you’re pregnant, when you’re breastfeeding, all these other things. It might be that the women who experienced and learned all this with their hormones kind of just functioning as they’re naturally meant to, then when they go on the pill, it doesn’t affect them as much.
Sheila
But what if you didn’t ever do that?
Rebecca
Well, what if you’re 21 years old? You’re an evangelical. Getting married hasn’t had sex before. You’re on the pill. You don’t realize that it’s lowering your libido. You don’t have those natural hormone surges that are helping you get there. And then your first time having sex you. We hear this from women all the time. Yeah. Where they realize, like, they thought they had no libido, they thought they hated sex. They got off the pill to get pregnant. They’re like. Woo!
Sheila
Yeah, I hear that all the time, like it worked.
Rebecca
But we hear that a lot. And so if you’re someone who and that’s why like as, I just really get iffy about the conversation about contraception with high schoolers because people are like, also really important that a 16 year old doesn’t get pregnant. However, if you are a grown up getting married, use a condom.
Sheila
You can use a condom.
Rebecca
I also firmly believe that unless there are reasons to be on birth control or you have endometriosis. Heck yeah, get on that pill. Yeah, we love the pill if you have endometriosis. Thank you, Lord, for the pill. But if you don’t have a reason to be on this medication, it could be messing with your hormones. And why would you do this in hard mode?
Sheila
Yeah. Yeah, right. So that’s it.
Rebecca
Just a thing where you can think.
Sheila
I am going to read more or less what the conclusion is here. Okay. And so they’re saying that the bloom framework and bloom stands for what was bio psychosocial learning opportunities and outcomes model of gender differences. The bloom framework proposes that adolescence is not only when sex is least equal, but also when sex is most teachable and most likely to instill lasting lessons. Unlike models that attribute women’s sexual interest solely to evolved biological differences or experience dependent learning across the life course, bloom emphasizes the formative impact of experience during evolutionary catalysis. Development when particular experiences are expected, and we may be biologically primed to learn from them because of the unique neuro hormonal and psychosocial backdrop of puberty, including elevated brain plasticity, non-linear changes in reward and threat, reactivity, and consolidation of identity and memory. Sexual experiences in adolescence carry unique salience and emotional weight. Sex may thus be particularly meaningful, motivating, and memorable precisely when it’s particularly inequitable. We therefore propose that adolescence is not merely a vulnerable point for sexual problems, but also a window of opportunity for cultivating sexual desire and an inflection point for the emergence of gender differences and sexuality.
Rebecca
Yeah. And really, the takeaway that I think people should get from that is that we need to be careful not to be threatening and punishing our children around sex. In a way that creates a really unequal experience. And remember that this doesn’t mean 13 year olds. It also means your 18 to 24 year olds. Because I know the things that make people angry.
Sheila
Yeah. And don’t do sex on hard mode. And if you have kids that are currently in that puberty, remember to get the Whole Story. We do this for you. And everything that we teach in the whole story is consistent with what this paper is recommending.
Rebeca
We did that. We did that. Yeah. And I think yeah, but I think, I think there’s a there’s a good question that we can have as parents, which is how do we as, as religious Christian parents who wanted to live a chaste life, how do we and this is a weird question to ask, how do we ensure that our children are having positive sexual experiences? I know that’s a weird question to ask, but yeah, often so much of that is about shutting down. Shutting down. Where are the places where we can allow them to go? And I have an example of what you did wrong. Do you want to tell me, do you want to give an example now first.
Sheila
Oh, he does the example, then I’ll make another conclusion. Okay.
Rebecca
So one of the things that I do and I’m going to really put you on blast here.
Sheila
That’s okay, I’m ready for it.
Rebecca
I genuinely believe that when I was in junior high, I struggled so much with self-esteem. And I am so much with feeling like I was, you know, at all likable or just even desirable in a healthy way. I didn’t want to have sex. I didn’t even want to have a boyfriend. I just have to know that people saw me and liked me, and I fit in, right? And I had so many types of clothing that I thought were really, like, so feminine. And yeah, and because it emphasized my curves, because guess what, I wasn’t skinny. Yeah, I’m more curvy than you.
Right. And you saw me with my bigger boobs. And you didn’t let me wear any clothes that emphasized them. I should have been able to. It would have genuinely helped. Yeah. Let me like, this actually isn’t a bad part of me. But instead I was hearing Danny Crash, who also was. Yeah. Chested. A very skinny woman. And no offense. Yeah, yeah, I was not allowed to embrace the soft, warm, feminine nature of my body. And that was a positive experience I then got two years later.
Sheila
But your sister had it at a younger age than you.
Rebecca
And she has always felt more confident in her body than I do. Yeah. And I think that’s a big thing where it’s like just those little things where we can freak out because we see our kids as, oh, they’re being sexual. No, they actually get to feel. Like your kid’s body shape is different from yours. Like they actually get to experience that. And to us that’s, that’s like an example.
Sheila
Yeah. We get an example. Yes. Especially ones of how I messed up. You know, but actually this is important because I messed up and you’re still good. That’s exactly what I was about. And the reason you’re still good is because we could talk about it.
Rebecca
Yes. You know I was about to say that. Too.
Sheila
And I messed up and back then. And I’m still good now, too, because we can all grow. And that’s what we’re supposed to be doing because it’s.
Rebecca
About this, this balance. It’s an ongoing conversation. And this is like the easiest time to learn. Doesn’t mean that it stops too. Right? Like you. Yeah, I’m 12. And I’d be like, hey, I actually disagree with that. Now let’s change this right? Yeah. To Josh Harris kissing. And by 14 and by 15 we were like oh this is all bunk. And so it didn’t affect us. Yeah. Right. And so I just anyway I hope that yeah some people are encouraged when they’re like, oh, I don’t have to be perfect.
Sheila
Yeah. You know you really don’t. You really don’t. And that’s what we teach in the Whole Story too. Okay. Now. Last thing before we end this discussion, there was one thing I wish they had talked about more that they didn’t. They didn’t mention the effects of porn or erotica. And I think those play a really big role in adolescence. And it would be interesting to see. I mean, there’s been so many articles about how porn is quite destructive among teenagers, but it would be interesting to see the role that novels play. Yeah, it just wasn’t there. And so we can’t really comment on it because it wasn’t in the article. But I know reading through that’s one thing that I kept thinking. And you might have been thinking that too.
Rebecca
So yeah. Yeah, I know from a research perspective and this isn’t this isn’t this is me talking from a research perspective, not from a personal moral conviction state perspective. Right. Well, I would be curious how you would measure that a bit because you’d have to have a whole separate survey about the kinds of stuff they watched in porn, how often it was. Porn either can be something that is like okay, this is from a research, not a personal moral standpoint. You can like ethical porn was is not ethical porn. You can like violent porn versus what would be less like. Yeah. What do we define? Are we putting Bridgerton in this? Yes. I can understand why they didn’t have it because I’m like that would be a study in itself.
Sheila
But that’s such a that’s all of this about that. Yeah. Because that’s such a big part of so many people’s learning experiences. And I know as a mom I would you know, you’re, you’re petrified of kids reading anything with sex scenes in it. But like if it’s a healthy sex scene between two people who have it. Is that actually such a bad thing? I don’t know, I don’t have the answers to that.
Rebecca
But, like, I’m sorry. If your girl at age 17 or 16, like, finds out that like, you know, you can have sex that feels good for her because she’s reading very. Yeah. Romance novels that have like one sex thing.
Sheila
Isn’t that good to expect that? Doesn’t that change what you expect?
Rebecca
I don’t know the answer. Yeah. I think that these are, these are conversations that are going to be individual, which is another plug for the Whole Story and because in the Whole Story, we are not a replacement for you, we are a resource. All in all seriousness, these kinds of conversations are ones that you need to have with your kids and our kids as they get older. Right? What’s allowed for an 11 year old should not be the same as not for a 17 year old, and that’s a big thing that purity culture did wrong. Yeah, the rules were the same for each age. Yeah. And so if you do do a course, there are lots of checking points. And that’s why we actually did it in two different ages as well. Mind you, like, these conversations are not just a one time thing. Yeah. This should be a check in multiple times.
Sheila
Let me end with one thing, because, one of the reasons I think, that parents are so scared of talking about the fact that sex is pleasurable or that women can orgasm, I like I had a really hard time telling you that. Like, it just wasn’t something that I even knew how to tell you. And the Whole Story does that for you, by the way. But when we looked at our research for She Deserves Better, we found that the age when you learned that women could orgasm. Highly correlated with everything good. Like, if you the younger you learned it, the better everything was for the rest of your life your self-esteem, your choice of marriage partner, even making good decisions about sex like, we think that if we tell girls and boys about the mechanics of sex, about how pleasurable it is that they’re going to run out and do it, it’s actually the opposite. And that’s what this study said, too. So let me read this to you. Sex positive pleasure inclusive programs are associated with less risky sexual behavior among girls and confer the lowest risk of sexual victimization to women. The more girls know about sex ed, and even the more they know about like, sex positive things like that. It feels good that you’re supposed to orgasm, etc. the less likely they are to be abused and victimized because they understand their body. Because they understand what’s happening. They understand when something isn’t right.
Rebecca
Some guy starts telling them stuff about how, oh, I know this is totally normal. No one has. No one uses a condom during sex. They’re like, oh, that’s a red flag. Yeah, and I’m leaving immediately. You’re just trying to use me.
Sheila
Yeah. And so, like, there really aren’t downsides. And so we just want to make sure that we’re giving those positive messages, which again, does not mean that we don’t have to talk about values. Okay. But it does mean that we don’t use threats and punishment. And we try not to put adolescents on hard mode and early adulthood on hard mode as much as possible. So check out the Whole Story. If you have kids that are sort of between 10 and 16, or even if you have kids coming up, you know, you can then you’ll have the course for life saving if you buy it now. And your kids are 7 or 8, it’ll be ready when you’re ready and it’ll still be there. So I just use the Coupon Code podcast. The link is in the podcast notes of where you can get it. It’s 25% off right now. And yeah. Thank you for listening. I don’t think we’ve ever done this where we did a whole podcast on one article.
Rebecca
Yes, I think we did it once before, but yeah, and very rarely I think we do the ravioli.
Sheila
I think we had several. We had several articles. One though this is a big one. I talked about everything. So I’m reviewing so much. Yeah. And it put together about 300 different studies into one, one model that they were trying to create. So all of the links we got to all the articles are in the podcast notes. And yeah, just remember that women don’t naturally have lower libidos. We just have worse early experiences. And so let’s do what we can to change that. All right.
Thanks everybody. We’ll see you next week.
Rebecca
Bye bye!














0 Comments