Complementarians Approach the Bible the Same Way Pro-Slavery People Did

by | Oct 28, 2026 | Theology of Marriage and Sex | 9 comments

The Whole Story Ad

Defending slavery and defending male only leadership in the church and the home use the same hermeneutic.

My husband Keith has been writing a series of the deceptive ways that complementarians approach Scripture, and today is the final post in the series. He’s looked at how they rip verses out of context and ignore the metanarrative; how they accuse egalitarians of just following culture when they actually do that; and how they insist on literalism so that it impedes women, but not if it could impede men.

Today he’s wrapping it all up.

It’s based on the interactions he has with complementarians on social media, who refuse to approach the Bible in an intellectually honest way. He finds it so frustrating, and so wanted to get all his thoughts out in one place!

Sheila Wray Gregoire

How do we approach Bible interpretation honestly?

There’s an old joke about a tourist who gets lost on backroads, so asks a local farmer for directions to “City-of-your-choice”. The farmer replies, “Well, if I were you, I wouldn’t start from here.”

It’s certainly a humorous way to point out that sometimes the starting point matters more than the destination.

This is my last of four posts in a series on how different ways of approaching the Bible affect our views about women’s place within the home and the church.

As already stated, I’m not a theologian. For the actual Biblical arguments I would refer you to works like Philip Payne’s “The Bible vs Biblical Womanhood” and Terran Williams “How God Sees Women”. Also, I am not an apologist. So I am not writing any of this to convince opponents or to give you a manual to do so. I am just a Christian who takes the Bible seriously and who takes real world evidence seriously and my goal is simply to share how I put those together in the hopes that it will also help you.

There are three key differences I see between the way I and those who oppose mutual submission in marriage interpret Scripture.

1. The first is how we balance individual verses with the whole.

As I discussed in the first post, I (like others who would empower women) see a metanarrative of freedom in Scripture which should inform how we interpret the verses that seem to restrict women.

The counterargument by those who would restrict women is that we are reading our culture into the Bible and that overarching themes like Galatians 3:28 (“There is no longer…male and female”) are vague and need to be interpreted in light of verses such as Ephesians 5:22 (“wives, submit to your husbands”) which are clear.

I addressed the first half of that counterargument in my second post where I showed that equality is an idea, not a “culture”, and it is in fact they who are caving to culture by trying to preserve a male-centric society despite the evidence of women’s equality. I addressed the second half in my third post where I showed how their definitions of clear and vague are highly suspect.

But let’s leave the argumentation aside for a second and just note that we have two hermeneutical options in sorting out Gal 3:28 and Ephesians 5:22.

 

 Egalitarians argue ideals like Galatians 3:28 should triumph and we should have mutual submission in marriage.

Complementarians argue that verses that specifically instruct practice supercede abstract notions and that the presence of a clear command in Ephesians 5:22 to keep the social hierarchy of men over women means we must interpret Gal 3:28 exclusively in a spiritual sense.

2. The second difference is that complementarians say you can’t use anything to intepret other than the Bible.

I also addressed this in my third post, but essentially the issue is that  those who argue for the limitation of women distrust logical and philosophical arguments as “worldly notions” and want to keep the discussion strictly to the text of the Bible. Using philosophy, logic or evidence of the actual effects of theology in the real world as a basis for argument are all “off-limits”.

For example, the argument that it is philosophically impossible for two people to be equal while one is in a permanent, arbitrary, unchangeably lower position falls on deaf ears. It doesn’t have to make sense, because “God said it” and “His ways are higher than our ways”. Similarly, how do we handle the fact that marriages that function as a team of equals have better results than those who practice hierarchy? Is that admissible data or not? Should it aid us in our interpretation of Scripture, or do we need to view such data with suspicion?

We again see two approaches:

Egalitarians see equality and marital hierarchy as philosophically contradictory and see real world proof that mutuality works better, so they interpret the Bible in that light.

Complementarians argue that we must be faithful to God’s word which requires yielding our human logic to God’s revealed truth

3. The third difference is how we handle things that offend our moral sensibilities

I haven’t dealt with this one yet, and that’s what I’d like to do with the rest of this article. How do we handle our natural reactions to things we find in the Bible that seem unjust or otherwise objectionable?

Here we find again two starkly contrasting approaches:

Egalitarians tend to follow a hermeneutic where they believe The Holy Spirit indwelling us can speak to our conscience which has been cleansed by Christ’s sacrifice (Hebrews 9:14 & 10:22) and guide us into the best way to interpret Scripture

Complementarians tend to follow a hermeneutic where they believe they must reject such twinges of conscience because our hearts are “deceitful above all things and desperately wicked” (Jer 17:9)

For those who wish to ensure the submission of women in the church and home, allowing “emotional” data into the equation is completely forbidden. In their mind, challenging the justice of what seems normative in Scripture undermines the authority of Scripture itself. If it is prescribed in Scripture, who are we to challenge it? One man told me that in interpreting Scripture we are surely in error if we start “appealing to personal experience as proof, appealing to emotions rather than exegesis…[and]…elevating personal conviction above Scripture.”

That’s when a light bulb switched on in my brain. The wording of the argument sounded so familiar that it triggered an aha moment. For example, consider this argument:

“…the Bible is the only infallible standard of moral truth and human duty…Our benevolence is not to be a matter of mere human impulse or feeling, but it must be regulated by the word of God. We are not to set up our notions of what is good, and what is right, above the written law of God”

This quote, which sounds like it could easily come from the current online discussion about women’s roles in the church and home, in fact comes (as you may have guessed) from an address promoting the practice of chattel slavery given by George D Armstrong in Missouri in 1855.

In fact, all three of the hermeneutical choices I have laid out here have clear echoes in the debate that raged through the nineteenth century between the abolitionists and slaveholders. For instance, consider the first difference in hermeneutics I listed and this quote about Galatians 3:28 from Dr. Albert Taylor Bledsoe in an “An Essay on Liberty and Slavery” (1856):

This text [Galatians 3:28] is often cited by abolitionists as a direct condemnation of slavery. But it is obvious that the apostle is speaking of the spiritual condition of mankind, and not of their civil relations…It is only in a spiritual point of view that all are one in Christ Jesus. It does not beat down the social and civil distinctions of life. It leaves the master a master, and the servant a servant.

Dr. Albert Taylor Bledsoe

“An Essay on Liberty and Slavery” (1856)

In other words, to resolve the tension between the ideals of Scripture and day-to-day practice, Abolitionists argued in favour of the broad themes while slaveholders argued that verses instructing practice (Eph 6:5) rendered Gal 3:28 as “only spiritual”.

Sound familiar?

Next, consider how each side framed the utility of human logic and philosophical argument.

As far as logic vs “only the Bible” argumentation goes, consider this quote from (pro-slavery) Robert L Dabney:  

“… the cause of our defence is the cause of God’s Word, and of its supreme authority over the human conscience. For…that Word is on our side, and the teachings of Abolitionism are clearly of rationalistic origin, of infidel tendency”.

Robert L. Dabney

Finally, in the case of the third hermeneutical dichotomy, the abolitionists’ appeal to the inhumanity and cruelty of the practice of slavery (i.e. to conscience), were met by:

  1. a variety of paternalistic arguments that mixed lies downplaying the realities of what the slaves were experiencing with suggestions that equality for them would be worse; and
  2. the argument that, in any event, emotional reaction to the practice was no justification for it being abolished as God had clearly allowed it.

In fact, they argued that the idea that humans would oppose what God clearly allowed was the height of hubris. For example, George D Armstrong, whom I quoted previously, described it as “impiously to presume to be wiser than God.”

What I find mindboggling is how many current evangelicals agree with the abolitionists’ conclusions, while opposing the hermeneutical choices that abolitionists made to get to those conclusions.

Most evangelicals I dare say, given each of the three hermeneutic dichotomies I have presented here, in any other context would argue for the opposite choice as the abolitionists did in each case. Their overwhelming fear that they might dilute the authority of Scripture (based on the way they have been discipled) leaves them no other choice.

But then they give no serious thought to the uncomfortable fact that if a literal Biblical exegesis divorced from external evidence or experience is the most faithful way to interpret Scripture then unfortunately (in that paradigm) the pro-slavery argument becomes more compelling than abolitionism! To tritely say that slavers “misunderstood those Bible verses” will make you feel better only until you ask the logical question: “WHY did they misunderstand them?” The only honest answer is because the Biblical hermeneutic they were employing led them inexorably there. Asked how to start with that hermeneutic and get to freedom for the slaves, one has to give the answer the local farmer gave the lost tourist in that old joke: “Well, I wouldn’t start from here.”

The arguments against women’s full equality in the church and home rely on this same hermeneutic as the arguments promoting slavery.

And many people are swayed because they think this hermeneutic is “more faithful to Scripture” because it relies on nothing else. But it is clearly a broken hermeneutic. The fact that it led us down the wrong path two hundred years ago may not prove it will always lead us astray, but it certainly proves that it’s not 100% trustworthy. If I type 6×8 into a calculator and get 47, I don’t dismiss it as a fluke and trust it to give me other answers reliably. If a literalist, “Bible-only” hermeneutic failed in the 1800s to such a disastrous degree, why would you trust it to work now?

And the truth is that you can still have a high view of Scripture and hold it as your guide for life and faith, while also allowing your interpretation of it to be informed by things outside of it.

Interestingly, one famous way to do this is the “Wesleyan Quadrilateral” wherein Scripture is the foundation, but it is “affirmed by tradition, aligned with reason and vivified in our experience.” There are other paradigms as well and this is not meant as a specific plug for Wesleyanism. But as I was preparing and writing this post, I found it interesting how close each of these components (tradition, reason, experience) maps onto the three hermeneutical choices.

And I thought about how John Wesley fought for abolition his whole life, even writing a note from his death bed to William Wilberforce encouraging him to continue the fight against “that execrable villany.” And that the Wesleyans were one of the first churches to ordain women.

I can’t help but think that all of that is linked.

Why do you think complementarians refuse to see that they’re using the same hermeneutic that slavers did? Can we fix this? Let’s talk in the comments!

Written by

Keith Gregoire

Tags

Recent Posts

Want to support our work? You can donate to support our work here:

Good Fruit Faith is an initiative of the Bosko nonprofit. Bosko will provide tax receipts for U.S. donations as the law allows.

Keith Gregoire

Author at Bare Marriage

Keith has been married to Sheila for over 30 years! They met while he was in pre-med at Queen's University in Kingston, Ontario. He has served as Chief of Pediatrics in the Quinte Region, and has been the chair of undergraduate pediatric medical education at Queen's University, and participated in the Royal College examination board for new pediatricians. He is the co-author with Sheila of The Good Guy's Guide to Great Sex, and a new marriage book they're working on. An avid birder, he loves traveling with Sheila all over North America in their RV.

Related Posts

Comments

We welcome your comments and want this to be a place for healthy discussion. Comments that are rude, profane, or abusive will not be allowed. Comments that are unrelated to the current post may be deleted. Comments above 300 words in length are let through at the moderator’s discretion and may be shortened to the first 300 words or deleted. By commenting you are agreeing to the terms outlined in our comment and privacy policy, which you can read in full here!

9 Comments

  1. JG

    I grew up around the teachings of Complementarians. I honestly don’t think that people my parents’ age will change what they believe. I also think people my age (being in our 50s) have a difficult time breaking away from that teaching. The Josh Howertons in leadership see this teaching as convenient so they can coerce their wives into submission because seeing women as inferior hides their insecurity. Mutual submission works a lot better, but Complementarians just don’t want to see it.

    Reply
    • Sheila Wray Gregoire

      I would agree that to many it is a choice. But I hope that some women hear the truth!

      Reply
  2. Boone

    I’m curious as if you ever think putting your foot down is ever the thing to do. I’ve done it twice in my 37 year marriage. The first time was after we’d been married a little over a year. My wife made some bad choices in a situation that lasted about three and a half hours on a Friday night. The next morning I told her that these were the new rules to make sure nothing like that ever happened again.
    The second happened as a result of an ongoing situation with a business she had started and the student ministry at church. I tried several times to ask to be heard over about five years, including three attempts that turned into major arguments. After the last one I backed off because I had three children involved. When the last one aged out I thought that finally I was going to get my wife back. Things exploded at a Sunday school pot luck when the student pastor walked up with two four inch binders for her to do the rooming assignments for middle school camp. He also asked her to room with a particular person. Camp was three weeks away and I hadn’t even been told she was going. I just looked at her and said, “You’re going?” She replied yes. I took my ring off and threw in down in front of her and said, “I’m done competing for my wife.” I got up and left her at the church, went home and started packing. She arrived as I was leaving. I told her that I wasn’t going to tell her that she couldn’t go to camp. I would even give her a ride to church to catch the bus and carry her bags. I also told her if she went at 8:30 the next morning I was filing for divorce and she’d be served when the bus pulled in the next Friday. She asked me where I thought I was going. I replied, “I’m going somewhere to decide whether there’s anything left to save of this marriage.”
    That was Saturday. I came back total by agreement the following Wednesday. I told her that I was willing to try but these were the things that were going to have to change for it to work. She had already cut ties with the student ministry. I also told her this was no guarantee. She said she wanted to fix it so we did.

    Reply
    • Kristy

      I’m not qualified to give marriage advice or analysis, so I can’t comment on your specific situation. And I mean that seriously. But I don’t want to ignore your question, either, so maybe I can make some general observations and hope they will serve as a starting point for you to think through the question you have asked.

      Is it ever justifiable to “put[] your foot down”?

      Yes, if what you are really doing is drawing boundaries. Both you and your wife have the right to do that (but I caution that you need to read or get professional advice on what this is and when it is justifiable; it is not the same as simply insisting on getting your own way).

      No, if what you mean by “putting your foot down” is playing the male headship card (which isn’t a legitimate thing and therefore no one has the right to play it). If at any point you said, “I’m the man and so I’m making some rules, and you are going to follow them because I say so,” then you crossed the line into hierarchical behaviour and it would probably have been better to have said something like, “Your choices impact both of us and affect our marriage, so we need to sit down and discuss this. I think we need to set up some rules together that we both agree on.”

      You say that “she wanted to fix it so we did.” I hope that means that your marriage is now flourishing. If it isn’t, may I strongly suggest that you read Sheila and Keith’s *The Marriage You Want* as a really good starting point, and that if you need more, you and your wife find a certified counsellor to help you work through your issues.

      I’m glad you’re here and I appreciate your honesty and vulnerability. Blessings on both of you, Boone.

      Reply
  3. Headless Unicorn Guy

    “complementarians say you can’t use anything to interpret other than the Bible.”

    How does that differ from all the sermons during the “Last Temptation of Christ” brouhaha that all preached “THE BIBLE IS TRUE BECAUSE THE BIBLE SAYS THE BIBLE IS TRUE!”?

    And remember how the Bible interprets the Bible so the Demon Locust plague of Revelation is clearly helicopter gunships piloted by long-haired bearded hippies?

    “If I type 6×8 into a calculator and get 47, I don’t dismiss it as a fluke and trust it to give me other answers reliably.”

    Everybody knows the REAL answer (to Life, the Universe, and Everything) is FORTY-TWO, not 47.

    “Why do you think complementarians refuse to see that they’re using the same hermeneutic that slavers did?”

    Because it’s really hard to see the bad in something that personally benefits you.

    Reply
  4. Headless Unicorn Guy

    “For those who wish to ensure the submission of women in the church and home, allowing “emotional” data into the equation is completely forbidden.”

    How does that differ from the pop Stoicism of Manosphere Influencers firewalling the self-help playbook of the Late Roman Empire’s extinction burst? (Which itself differs from the source, which was a philosophy of maintaining self-control whatever the situation, not suppression of all emotions like a Star Trek Vulcan.)

    Remember all the sermons about The Sin of Empathy?

    Many years ago, there was a little-known series of Catholic space-opera novels (the Einai series) by “Simon Lang”, pen name for a Darlene Hartman. Best one-line Hollywood pitch session description of them was “Star Trek, with Rosaries”. (They did actually start out as Star Trek fanfic. But then, so did The Orville.)

    The Einai series’ bad-guy interstellar empire was a race called the Krail. The Krail were unemotional reason and rationality unencumbered by empathy, more Stoic than the Romulans, more Logical than the Vulcans, with a society like an interstellar North Korea. All rationalized and justified by reason and realism — Slavery as Efficient Use of Animate Resources, Genocide as Culling Surplus Population (the Weak and Defectives), Heirarchy as the Logical Order of Things, all totally rational, totally reasonable; pure Intellect without any interference from emotion or sentiment or empathy.

    Reply
  5. Alyssa

    Tragic parallels that unfortunately sound all too similar…I have actually heard people recently say (out loud and in person) that they thought slavery was not that bad because they were trying to defend a similar “hermeneutic” from the Bible. It’s horrifying and sickening.

    The whole “we’re spiritually one but not practically one” argument always gets me because I thought as Christians the point was living out our faith in spirit and in truth, in every area of our life? Shouldn’t the spiritual be infinitely practical? If something can be “spiritually” true but not “practically” true then I’m pretty sure it’s just not TRUE.

    I’m also beginning to suspect, the more I talk to defenders of women’s inferiority and subordinate “role,” that the folks saying “we’re the ones who really care about the Bible and what God wants” are using that as a blind…the real loadbearing wall that they don’t want to draw attention to is that they know these ideas will change everything they care about or want (the way they interact at church and work, how their see and treat their own wives who have sacrificed so much for them, how they interact with their daughters and sons, and even the way they see themselves). They are afraid to change. Afraid that their community will reject them if they try to remove or inspect this loadbearing wall, and because their community dictates and mediates their relationship with God (so they think), they believe God will reject them too.

    I’m realizing it takes a very secure individual to helpfully re-examine beliefs and practices they may have gotten wrong. Secure in themselves, secure in the love and trust of safe people, and secure in God’s love and “bigness” to be able to handle complex problems, questions and situations.

    I’m realizing a lot of these angry men are simply small and afraid.

    Sometimes I think those guys need to find their own way, or God will have to deal with them. But I think of the people I know in my life, friends and family, who I still care about, and I wonder: Are there ways I can target and reveal that loadbearing wall when they keep putting up decoy “reasons” for holding on to their beliefs? And can I do that lovingly, but without pulling punches?

    Reply
    • Marlita

      I think it is usually on a one to one basis that unfounded beliefs get changed. Indeed a primary motive for speaking about them has to be of concern and not to be superior in any way. I say: if the heart is right the words will come. There is a heaviness to this burden. You show much wisdom here. The Holy Spirit is with you.

      Reply
  6. Inkybinky

    I have been having running dialogue with my friend and she listened to someone talking about 1st peter 3:1-7. So.after she sent it to me I did some basic research into the context of the book. Its very obvious to me that its not a prescriptive (do this) type passage, but a how to, for the society they were in. The previous chapter was telling slaves to stay even if they were being flogged without cause. That it was “pleasing to God in their suffering”. Plain reading completely justified and justifies slavery! Which no mentally well adjusted person today would agree with. So I think its very reasonable to assume that the passages following it, dont say what they alleared to say! Emphasis on the husband treating her with respect and honor. Not her submission.

    Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *