6 Reasons Your Mind and Body May Not Connect During Sex

by | Dec 6, 2021 | Uncategorized | 12 comments

Why Mind Body Connection Doesn't Work During Sex

Sex would be so much easier if our bodies would just do what we want them to do, wouldn’t it?

Or if our minds would just get “in the game” when it was time?

Welcome to our Embodiment Series, where we’re talking about the mind-body connection. We’re going to start in the first bit of the month looking at how to get our minds and bodies lined up, and in the second half we’ll look at the importance of our physical bodies, leading up to Christmas and the incarnation (when Jesus took on human form).

Last week I talked about arousal non-concordance, and how it’s possible for your body to start getting aroused while your brain is not in the mood at all. And it’s possible for your brain to be in the mood–or to want to be in the mood–but your body doesn’t do much of anything.

Today let’s look at some of the common scenarios where there’s a mind/body disconnect when it comes to sex.

I have a routine I like to do about arousal non-concordance during my Girl Talk sex night at churches. I say that sometimes you can be having an awesome time, really enjoying yourself, and suddenly think, “is there milk in the fridge?” And before you know it you’re making a grocery list in your head, and you’re GONE. Or one night he can do something to you that has you in raptures, while three nights later he does exactly the same thing, move for move, and you’re lying there thinking, “will you just get it over with because I want to get to sleep!” It’s not about what he’s doing; it’s about what you’re thinking.

Now, that’s a big simplification, but you get the idea. When our minds and bodies aren’t in alignment with each other when it comes to sex, orgasm is often elusive. Or, if it’s not elusive, intimacy is often interrupted.

I’d like to look at some of the scenarios where this happens, and explain why it can happen, so that many of you readers will realize that you are not alone!

One big thing to understand as we begin: Your brain’s job is to protect you.

You’re actually designed to not desire sex mentally with someone who treats you badly, who is lazy, who in general would make a bad father. (That doesn’t mean that we can’t be attracted to “bad boys”; with everything, we’re very complex, and there are often other dynamics at work too). When we feel betrayed, taken for granted, or mentally overloaded with the burdens of the household, sex drive (or the mental component) can seriously suffer. Basically, our bodies don’t want to get pregnant, and they don’t want to become emotionally vulnerable to someone who doesn’t care for us well and isn’t trustworthy.

It’s like we explained in the Passion chapter at the end of The Great Sex Rescue: you can’t have great sex without the ability to trust and become vulnerable. We need everything firing all at the same time in order for sex to work well. But our bodies and minds have one main job: Keep her safe. (or keep him safe!). One of the big causes of arousal non-concordance is simply not being able to become vulnerable because of past trauma, past history, or current dynamics in your marriage. If there are currently things at play, like uneven mental load, feeling like your spouse doesn’t listen to you or care about you, betrayal trauma, or more, sex won’t fix it and sex can’t be fixed either. Those underlying things need to be dealt with first.

So that’s the main cause of arousal non-concordance, where your body may get a little bit lubricated and even feel a little bit good to his touch, but you just don’t want sex and won’t respond more than that. Or perhaps you have no desire at all.

Okay, now let’s move on to six others: And this isn’t an exhaustive list. :

1. You grew up learning to “turn off” your body

This was the chapter we weren’t intending to write for The Great Sex Rescue, but we heard so many people mention this phenomenon that it had to make it in there.

When girls grow up hearing “boys will push your sexual boundaries, so you need to be the gatekeeper”, then what happens? Whenever they’re in a makeout situation with a boyfriend/fiance, they’re paying desperate attention not to what their bodies are feeling, but to making sure they don’t go too far. They’re paying attention to what HE is feeling, not what SHE is feeling. One woman called it “spectator-ing”. Another said she felt like she was judging what was happening, rather than experiencing it.

Then, when you get married, you can’t turn that off. You’ve spent your whole life trying to separate your body from your mind, and it’s hard to integrate with your body again. Also, since you spent your life “analyzing” what was happening–is he breathing too hard; am I kissing right; am I still in control–then mindfulness has been broken. You can’t be mindful and just experience if you’re also constantly analyzing everyone’s performance (which is a natural thing to do when you’re told that you’re the gatekeeper).

2. You see sex as a distasteful or threatening thing

Here’s really the crux of The Great Sex Rescue: when you grow up hearing that men can’t control themselves around women and that lust is every man’s battle; that you have to have sex frequently or he’ll watch porn or have an affair; that you’re obligated to give him sex when he wants it; that sex is how a man experiences most emotions–well, sex seems threatening and empty and ugly. How can you let your guard down and experiencing something great?

And when we measured how many evangelical teachings affected women’s sexuality, we found that quite often it was not the husband who had convinced her of these things. It was often her church culture, and he may not even know what she was believing!

When we see sex as something we’re obligated to do, then sex becomes about “shoulds”: I should do this for him, I should be enjoying this. But as soon as we access this analytical side of our brain, we stop practising mindfulness. Instead of inhabiting our bodies and just experiencing, we’re in our brains again. And that often disrupts any desire or arousal. We need to get rid of the “shoulds”!

The Great Sex Rescue

Changing the conversation about sex & marriage in the evangelical church.

What if you’re NOT the problem with your sex life?

What if the things that you’ve been taught have messed things up–and what if there’s a way to escape these messages?

Welcome to the Great Sex Rescue.

3. Your husband never figured out how to physically arouse you, so the only way to get aroused is to fantasize

Here’s another problem (and often these build on each other, so a person experiencing #1 naturally moves towards #2): neither of you truly understand how arousal is supposed to work for women. You can’t understand why intercourse isn’t exciting for you, and he starts to wonder if you’re broken. Everyone is just really depressed about the whole sex situation. The husband feels great, but why doesn’t she? What’s wrong with her?

And she finds that if she stops thinking about what he’s doing, and starts fantasizing about a movie, or a scenario she read about once in erotica, or something else, she can get her body to kick in. So she’s getting aroused at the same time as they’re having intercourse, but it has nothing actually to do with what he’s doing. It’s mostly in her mind.

4. You have porn use/erotica use in your past, and your arousal is tied to that

If porn or erotica use has been in her past, this may be especially accelerated. She learned (and he learned, because this is a big issue for guys as well) that the images or scenarios can be highly arousing. Focusing on those images or scenarios naturally led to arousal and orgasm.

And so the sexual response cycle has largely been fueled by what your mind is thinking or experiencing, rather than what your body is experiencing. In effect, you need the porn or erotica to jumpstart the arousal process, because arousal has become almost entirely about what you’re fantasizing about rather than what your body is feeling. In order to feel aroused, then, you escape in your head, or “dissociate”, from your body to conjure up images or scenarios from fantasy. Your body responds, and the desire for sexual stimulation is there, but it’s not being met by what’s happening to your body, but rather fueled by your mind.

5. You have abuse or trauma in your past that you dealt with through dissociating

This “dissociation”, though, is even more commonly a protective mechanism. Many sexual assault survivors deal with their assault and their trauma by thinking about anything else while the abuse is occurring. They get used to “leaving” their body and escaping into their mind. In a way, then, their bodies feel dead. They may not know how to experience pleasure or how to enjoy touch because as soon as it happens, they break that mind-body connection.

Again, this was a protective mechanism, and it’s not your fault. But you likely have to deal with the trauma first before you can learn to re-integrate. Please see a licensed counselor trained in evidence-based trauma therapies to help your brain stop this trauma response.

6. You’re not practising mindfulness during sex

Finally, it may not be anything nefarious or bad or anything bad in your past. You could simply have a really active brain and you figure, “when stuff starts to feel good I’ll concentrate on sex,” but until then you tend to think about anything else while he’s kissing you. You’re thinking through your schedule for tomorrow; you’re planning that grocery list; you’re wondering about that conversation you had with your sister earlier today. It’s not really a deliberate thing–it’s just normal stream of consciousness thinking.

But when you’re allowing your brain to leapfrog over all of these different things, then arousal is unlikely to register or to grow. As we talked about at the end of last week’s podcast, sex feels best when both of you allow your brains to be mindful of what is happening and experience what is happening, without any analysis. That means turning that one part of your brain off and just concentrating on breathing and experiencing (more on that later this month!).

The big picture: Understand that experiencing desire for your husband and for sex is a complex thing.

Past trauma can influence it. Our teachings about sex can influence it. The dynamics when we were dating or when we first start sex can influence it. No wonder so many of us have difficulty!

But there’s also good news, and it’s this: If desire starts in the brain, then we actually do have some control over it. We can learn how to practice mindfulness. We can learn to re-integrate with our bodies. It doesn’t need to stay this way!

So today: Thank your body and mind if you need to for being protective to you! Honestly. It could be that a lot of the problems that you’ve been experiencing are really protective in origin. Think about getting help if you need it, to deal with past trauma or to quit porn or erotica use.

And let’s move forward in learning not to dissociate but instead to re-integrate with our bodies. That’s when you’ll experience BOTH intimacy and desire at the same time. That’s when passion comes alive. And I hope I can give you some tools to get there!

Be on the Lookout!

I’ve got two GREAT revamped products coming soon that deal in detail with arousal non-concordance, dissociation, and re-establishing that mind-body connection. Over the holidays we’re refilming all the videos for my Boost Your Libido course! We’ve added some info and I’m so stoked about how it’s turning out! We should launch that in January (and if you’ve already bought the course, you’ll have access to all the upgraded materials as well).

And in my re-written Good Girl’s Guide to Great Sex, which is available for pre-order now, I’ve gone into even more detail than the original version about dissociation. So excited to share these with you soon!

6 Reasons for Arousal Non-Concordance

What do you think? Does one in particular resonate with you? Let me know in the comments!

Our Embodiment Series

And check out:

Sheila Wray Gregoire

Sheila Wray Gregoire

Founder of Bare Marriage

Sheila is determined to help Christians find biblical, healthy, evidence-based help for their marriages. And in doing so, she's turning the evangelical world on its head, challenging many of the toxic teachings, especially in her newest book The Great Sex Rescue. She’s an award-winning author of 8 books and a sought-after speaker. With her humorous, no-nonsense approach, Sheila works with her husband Keith and daughter Rebecca to create podcasts and courses to help couples find true intimacy. Plus she knits. All the time. ENTJ, straight 8

Related Posts

Do You Feel not Spiritual Enough

Do you feel like God is constantly disappointed in you? I’m enjoying some downtime this summer,...

Written by

Sheila Wray Gregoire


Recent Posts

Want to support our work? You can donate to support our work here:

Good Fruit Faith is an initiative of the Bosko nonprofit. Bosko will provide tax receipts for U.S. donations as the law allows.

Sheila Wray Gregoire

Author at Bare Marriage

Sheila is determined to help Christians find biblical, healthy, evidence-based help for their marriages. And in doing so, she's turning the evangelical world on its head, challenging many of the toxic teachings, especially in her newest book The Great Sex Rescue. She’s an award-winning author of 8 books and a sought-after speaker. With her humorous, no-nonsense approach, Sheila works with her husband Keith and daughter Rebecca to create podcasts and courses to help couples find true intimacy. Plus she knits. All the time. ENTJ, straight 8

Related Posts

Is Someone Stepping on Your Air Hose?

So many women--and many men as well--honestly feel like the church is hurting them. I do not believe that it is Jesus that is hurting them, but the things that the church teaches, especially around sex and marriage, do cause harm. Our surveys have shown that...


We welcome your comments and want this to be a place for healthy discussion. Comments that are rude, profane, or abusive will not be allowed. Comments that are unrelated to the current post may be deleted. Comments above 300 words in length are let through at the moderator’s discretion and may be shortened to the first 300 words or deleted. By commenting you are agreeing to the terms outlined in our comment and privacy policy, which you can read in full here!


  1. Love not blinded

    I’ve reached the point, where I can kiss, I’m just struggling with wanting to. My mind is analyzing the memory of kissing, and can’t seem to remember any pleasure..or point.
    We’re both working on brushing our teeth now and I’m wondering, if hygiene is why I am not having good memories.(pregnancy made anything mouth highly triggering til now)

    He’s always avoided oral hygiene, because he’s got a lot of dental work to do(which is an obvious cycle of pain, caused by denial). it’s a remnant of his depression past. So we’ve been slowly getting him appointments and fixing his teeth.
    I foresee a slow recovery for our kissing life.

  2. Anon

    I’m a man so this may not apply to me but I have experienced this recently with a certain sex act. It’s not a weird sex act or anything. It’s been one of my wife’s and I favorite positions but recently I get anxiety and I go soft. No explanation at all to why.

    My wife was very hurt the first time it happened. Took several weeks for us to have sex again.

    We tried again several weeks after and the same thing happened. Lost my erection and even changing position didn’t help. Lost my sensitivity. I wanted sex but couldn’t perform until my wife let me just enjoy her body and that helped and everything went well after that.

    But it still bugs me. We haven’t really talked about it. It’s seriously one of our favorite things and not being able to do it stresses me out.

    I am recovering from porn but honestly I was never interested of watching that position so I can’t see how that can affect it. I have had problems with other more porn related but the more time away from porn the better that had gotten but this I can’t understand.

    This has given me a glimpse of how this can be for women. To have struggle with this almost all the time must be so tough.

  3. CMT

    Wow I think almost all of these (except 4 and 5) resonate to me in one way or another. The “should” was the killer for me.

    I “should” say yes unless I’m sick and feeling absolutely awful.

    This “should” feel good.

    I “should” hurry up.

    I “should” I enjoy myself so he’s not disappointed.

    This is also very true in my experience: “quite often it was not the husband who had convinced her of these things.” For me, probably 75% or more of the pressure I felt was internal. It has been a challenge to both communicate my experience to my husband, and the ways he has unintentionally contributed in the past, while also making clear that I don’t blame him. Any thoughts?

    • CMT

      Unrelated but-will there be a way to ask questions during the webinar tonight?

      • Sheila Wray Gregoire

        You will be able to submit questions! I don’t know how many we’ll get through, but we’ll try!

        • CMT


  4. Rebecca

    I sometimes have this sort of disconnect happen if I’m very tired- particularly post & breastfeeding. Our hormonal balance is totally different when breastfeeding and sometimes I’ll say to my husband “I want to have sex but my body is saying no”. Or we’ll start but then the desire I had initially just evaporates.

    It’s not anything to do with our relationship or anything else you mentioned- it’s simply my body’s got a lot going on and occasionally sex is just too much to handle.

    It’s not an issue for us – my husband is quite happy to leave it til another time when we are both into it – but if a husband is pressuring his wife to have sex when she’s feeling how I mentioned above ^^ I can imagine that turning into a vicious cycle because he isn’t giving her the rest, space, and feeling of safety that she needs at a very vulnerable time.

  5. Liv

    Maybe this is something you’ll cover later in the series, but: when is it appropriate to start practicing the mind-body connection? Me and my boyfriend are in our late twenties, waiting until marriage and have set clear boundaries based on mutual trust and respect rather than fear. We aren’t struggling with sticking to those boundaries even if we enjoy exploring and adventuring within them. However, I definitely relate to making out and not enjoying it as much as I’m actually able to because I want to stay in control. I trust my boyfriend completely, it’s just that I’m not sure what I would do if I get too carried away. I want to pull my weight and not put all of the boundary keeping responsibility on him. I have tried consciously shutting off my brain and being completely present and it makes a huge difference, but part of me feels like it’s not necessary for me right now to “feel all the feelings” so to speak, since we’re not even engaged yet. However, another part of me thinks it’s wise to practice having a solid mind-body connection now so it won’t cause trouble later. Any thoughts? 🙂

    • Anon

      I used to find this so hard when we were dating and engaged, as the message I’d been given growing up was that you could go from one kiss to full-on intercourse in seconds, so even a simple hug or kiss (in public) would have me worrying that we were going to suddenly turn into two sex maniacs, unable to control ourselves! Once I realised that it just doesn’t happen that fast and takes a lot of ‘warm-up’ time to progress from one to the other, I felt a lot safer. If you’re not being tempted to go beyond your boundaries, I wouldn’t worry. It’s when you start wanting to push those boundaries that you need to back off.

      I also don’t think it helps when you have Christian writers saying things like ‘if you’re not struggling to keep your hands off each other, you should rethink getting married because you might struggle to have sex’. It made me worry that because we weren’t constantly struggling not to have sex, we wouldn’t want it when we were married.

      A lot of these authors seem to confuse looking forward to being able to have something in the future and wanting to have it now. If I say I’m looking forward to icecream for dessert tonight, no one assumes I’m wanting to start eating icecream now. But a lot of Christian authors seem to think that you can’t look forward to sex when you’re married without wanting to have sex now!

  6. EOF

    Most of these resonate, and it’s sad how many of the problems can be led back to church teachings.

    And in that vein, I experience a problem you didn’t mention in the post. I spent so many years living under the false and problematic church teachings (such as, never say he’s doing anything wrong & make him feel like “the man” in the bedroom) that I ended up either angry or in tears during sex (or both) every time. Now I have to learn how to get aroused without getting angry first.

  7. Marie

    Thank you for articulating #3. I realized after many years that was my primary struggle, but I didn’t understand how to break out of it and just fell into trying to get through sex because “he needed it
    “. So now we are trying to work through the arousal part and get rid of the obligation part and I’m still trying to learn to not turn to fantasy and just experience without analyzing. This article was just the encouragement I needed today!


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *